 Ermengarde 2008-02-02 . chapter 15OK, finally got round to reviewing! I love the way you portray Barty, the more I read the more it just seems to fit- the irony, the inner conflict and his relationships with other characters... just perfect.
This fic had definiely given me lots to think about and the format (each chapter as a One-Shot) has sorted out a problem I was having with a piece of original fiction. So, thank you. I look forward to reading more.
Ermengarde |
 Meryl12 2008-01-13 . chapter 15I never really thought of Peter as brave before, but with that definition of brave, which is the one I believe too, he does have those qualities... hm, this one definitely made me think |
 computercatastrophe 2008-01-11 . chapter 15I liked this look at Wormtail and Barty together. There must have been lots of time for these little chats at the beginning of GoF. Nice perspective on Gryffindor/Slytherin notions of courage. But I'm not sure I recognised the fanatic "I shall be dearer to him than a son" Barty of GoF.
Regards
Possum |
 toujourspurPAL 2007-12-18 . chapter 11 ha...I love that poem. Twas brillig... ah, bliss. You've done quite well here, really captured him. And especially his father. And the Cruciatus is quite good as well.
~ toujours pur |
 HeyEugene 2007-12-11 . chapter 4I never thought of Barty and Sirius being alike. This is interesting, original, and well written. |
 HeyEugene 2007-12-11 . chapter 2You know it's well written when you have more pity for the butterflies killed than the people in the raid. Interesting insight. |
 computercatastrophe 2007-11-16 . chapter 14Good picture of what it must be to live under the Imperius Curse.
Regards
Possum |
 Fragile-Strength 2007-11-14 . chapter 14Wow, that was gorgeous! I think this is my favorite of your pieces by far (and so far, for that matter) and knowing me, it's probably mainly because of how wonderfully you managed to pull off the disjointed feel of it but still make it flow.
And looking back on that sentence, I'm realtively sure that's impossible.
OH WELL. =P There you go, you pulled off the impossible! =P
You've got Barty so wonderfully, and you seem to have some sort of 'insider' knowledge as to what having the Imperius Curse placed on you is like, when we all know that's impossible.
...-shifty-...
=P Anyway, I loved it, per usual.
-Cayenne |
 Lexie-H 2007-11-14 . chapter 14Oh! Your rainbow story! I do adore this, really, it's a beautiful characterisation of Barty and an amazing use of the motivation we gave you all =) Love it, even more so second time around! |
 Lexie-H 2007-11-12 . chapter 13"Imagine there's no purebloods"
Perfect. So very Sirius, and just... very very clever. How did you come up with that one?
I liked this chapter - the fact that Regulus also used Snape's textbook, and the fact that Snape and Regulus seem to be vaguely friendly, which is such a contrast to Sirius and Snape (and then, it's strange again, because Regulus seems to have a yearning for his brother while still managing to be friendly with Snape)
And I liked Barty's almost obsessive fixation with labelling Snape, and the fact that he struggled to do so. It says so much about both characters. Well done! |
 Fragile-Strength 2007-11-09 . chapter 13Wow, this is suprememly interesting!
My favorites are probably Fall and Royal and Never; I especially love the way you portrayed Bella as having complete control over her husband, Barty and (in her mind) the Dark Lord, and Barty having control of Reggie (poor thing).
You cast a very interesting Barty, and a very good Narcissa, Snape and Regulus and a ridiculously entertaining if a little-more-sane-then-I-like-her Bella.
I hope you're going to continue this; I'm very interested in keeping up. =)
-Cayenne |
 Possum132 2007-10-16 . chapter 13I know this is supposed to be about Barty, but the glimpses of the absent Sirius and Snape were fascinating. |
 bonniedoll 2007-10-04 . chapter 12Ooh... Drama! So dark, and... weird, as always! Love it, update soon! |
 bonniedoll 2007-10-04 . chapter 11Wow! That was the best chapter yet, by far. I remember seeing that chalenge on the forum; there were some really good ones, but I've never read this one. Shame. |
 bonniedoll 2007-10-04 . chapter 10Poor Regulus... Another fantastic chappie! ^_^ |