 SuperxXxGirl79 2009-07-29 . chapter 1that was definetely fluffy and definetely awesome. gr8 story! |
 Lee Scoresby 2008-01-26 . chapter 1Awesome and excellent! I don't know if a better post-ending could have been written. I actually though as I watched the movie that Jesse would end up killing himself although you added the military bit to it. Again, great one-shot. |
 Story Weaver1 2007-08-24 . chapter 1What's so unhappy about this one?Of course it's sad he died but givent he state he was in, it's not too bad. But that ending was pretty happy in my opinon. |
 Maline Elensar 2007-07-01 . chapter 1really good |
 misken67 2007-06-26 . chapter 1Wow! That was such a sweet ending. I wouldn't be surprised if you were Bush, that speech is exactly like his speeches. Amazing detail! |
 Rogue-90 2007-06-23 . chapter 1I loved this story, I want to thank MadTom for helping to inspire me, and help speed up the writing process of my first chapter which should be out soon. This story though dark was so well writen it had me hanging onto every word. The ending was wonderful and (I hate to say this) but it was sweet, and just how I would imagine them finding eachother in the end. Pease I'm begging you please keep up the great work and post more of these awesome stories. |
 hollly 2007-06-20 . chapter 1this is great. there was so much great detail. especially the military details. i also loved your other one:groundhog day |
 Coeus 2007-06-15 . chapter 1I really enjoyed this story. It's very well written, uses an effective structure, and has an interesting take on Jess's later life, and shows how much impact Leslie had on him (and Janice), and by proxy on those around him. Nicely done.
The only bit of criticism I would offer up is probably more just a case of personal preference. I would have liked the ending scene better without the romantic overtones, with most of the dialog and the kiss removed from the story. In fact, I would have probably made them 11 years old again, as when he had last seen her. But, of course, it's your fic. Like I said, purely a personal preference, and it doesn't detract from the rest of the story.
Excellent work. One of the better Bridge to Terabithia fanfics I have read. I hope to see more from you. |
 fledge 2007-04-25 . chapter 1Well, a bit difficult to comment on this...
As a psychologist, you'll know much better than me how plausible this sustained death-wish might be. Somehow I feel it doesn't really go with the end of the book/movie: May Belle helps him to get over his feeling of guilt, doesn't she? So why the death-wish that remains for some eight or nine years? I very much like Janice's description - there's another person that Leslie redeemed. And the end is sweet enough to make up for the darkness of the beginning - the title of this fic is well chosen. (Not everybody will probably understand what the "seventy-two of us" is supposed to be all about.) Sergeant Caulfield's first name cannot be Holden, much as I'd love it to be - he will be far too old by now.
What I find a bit hard to swallow is your attitude towards war in general and this special war in particular. By linking it to CSL's book you indicate it is a JUST war, even the terminal fight of good vs evil, which, I'm sorry, it is clerly not, IMHO. |
 LuvtoWrite 2007-03-29 . chapter 1LOVE the edning! It was so sweet and sadd! |
 IDoNotJudge 2007-03-25 . chapter 1this was just brilliant, i was almost crying at the end! You're a great writer, this was very dark but I could see it happening and I'm so glad he got to be with Lelsie at the end! |
 NarnianMelody 2007-03-25 . chapter 1I loved this.
It was dark, yes, but it was very realistic and I liked how you pulled Janice into the story. And the ending was simply beautiful, with Jess dying and going to Terabithia/Heavenm, with Leslie waiting there for him. Outstanding job! |