|Reviews for A Benevolent Punishment|
| dem bones 5/9/13 . chapter 15
I just finished reading all fifteen chapters of this story and am very impressed with how easily I am submerged into this fic.
The amount of research that was put into this is just impressive and really enhances the story if anything. At times I felt I was there. All the OCs were very relatable and I just love the insight of Snape's character especially his way of teaching. It just seems to fit better for him then just passing his teaching off as incompetence.
That said it's a pity that this story has been put on the backburner for quite some time as it's a very interesting story and I kind of want to see what happens next.
| meg527 4/21/13 . chapter 15
This is a fabulous story! I'm so disappointed that it appears to have been abandoned. It's such a wonderful premise and a thoroughly engaging start.
| Guest 3/20/13 . chapter 2
Type your review for this chapter here...
| Shadock 2/15/13 . chapter 15
So ... I want the next chapter ! I can't wait ! Please
| Guest 2/2/13 . chapter 15
Amazing! I remember this story from years back and it's even better this time around. I do hope you haven't forgotten about it!
I hope to see an update soon! _
| PottersChick7 2/3/13 . chapter 4
So, definitely curious about what's going on here - I'm thinking Snape was given a new memory and made to live as a Muggle as much to protect him as to punish him (guessing from the title) and Hermione was involved in a magical accident; perhaps someone trying to do the same to her after she was injured but somehow her magic 'protected' her. BTW, love that you gave them their RL names as pseudonyms :)
| Henri Jane 1/16/13 . chapter 15
Finish this PLEASE! I like it, but its not even half done yet! Please. I like the direction it's going.
| Terahlyanwe 11/5/12 . chapter 15
This is extremely interesting! I think you have the portrayal of Severus down absolutely pat, but Hermione (Emma) just seems a mite...off..somehow.
| warner905 9/14/12 . chapter 15
Fantastic premise and cOncept. Please update soon!
| deedeebug 9/7/12 . chapter 2
I hope you get no flames. The subject matter while still taboo is so argued in the RW why can we not see it in fan fiction? I can not imagine having to make such a gut wrenching choice, but people do everyday and we must support those decisions if we care about those that make them.
| Aqua Are 9/1/12 . chapter 15
OMG, I've found this story completely by accident and I must admit it is rather addictive, so addictive that I seriously hope you have another chapter prepared soon or I'm going to have a heart attack xD
Do you have any idea how many chapters you have still to go? I'm dying to read it to the end, and soon xDD
Anyway, I really really like how you control Severus (poor Severin, such a horrible and ugly name, urgh), it's exactly how I've imagined all this years.
| louisethelibrarian 8/30/12 . chapter 1
I'm so excited to see an update for this! You are a marvelous writer, with great characterization skills. I can almost see the gears turning in Snape's head. more please!
| curvesforever 7/14/12 . chapter 15
Oooooh sneaky little man Snape. Can't wait to know what happens next!
| The Elven Daughter 7/1/12 . chapter 15
I really can't tell you how much I've been enjoying this story. I'd love to see you finish it. I find the whole concept intriguing and your writing really draws one in.
| Professor Severus Snape's Wife 6/30/12 . chapter 3
do you realize that his initials are A.S.S.? just checkin. but great story so far.