Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Discarded Material
Gothic-Romantic99 9/22/08 . chapter 1
This is so sad. I like that quote you use to start your story off with and I have to agree with him. I always liked the James/Growlie friendship, too bad he couldn't take the dog with him. I think it was a great idea to put this story in the dog's point of view, it makes it sadder to see it through his eyes. At least the ending is not completely tragic and leaves room for hope. Nice job with this.
AntiMusicMan 6/10/08 . chapter 1
poor Growlie...

we can never truly understand how or why people sever such close bonds. But at least there seems to be perhaps a faint glimmer of hope in this one... perhaps...
Sait 8/2/03 . chapter 1
Midako: *sniff* WAH! That was so sad...! *sniff sniff*

Midako's little brother: ...Baby.

M: *tears magically disappear* What?

MLB: I called you a baby. Nyah. :P

M: *glare*

MLB: EEp.

M: As I recall, YOU are the younger brother...

MLB: Yeah...

M: And that means you do what the older sister wants.

MLB: *gulp* yeah...

M: Go clean your room.

MLB: Yes ma'am! *runs off*

M: Better. Now, where was I...? Oh, right. *sniff* WA...

Midako
Untamed Shrew 8/10/02 . chapter 1
awwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww . that was so sweet, and so sad ;-;, I love it you can

really feel growlie and you can feel James' unselfishness. poor growlie, I want James

to see him again ;-; *cries* great work *huggles*
Brian-Lover Alex 3/30/02 . chapter 1
This so perfectly captures the essence of a dog's loyalty. Beautiful! (God, I need to find a Thesaurus, and find antonyms for "Beautiful")
Watashi Wa Mewtwo 7/18/01 . chapter 1
;_; Poor Growlie..But, that was a good story..I don't see how you could call your writings crappy..p
Yoshi Dude 7/14/01 . chapter 1
Growlie is so brave and kind! I hope they will be one day be reunited, never to be separated again. _
Blackjack Gabbiani 7/11/01 . chapter 1
Poor thing. James loves Growly, but he...Oh, James, you're so STUPID most of the time! (still love 'im, though)
Spiffy 7/10/01 . chapter 1
AWWWW! Poor little Growlie! You will see him again,he won't leeeeave you! ...*looks around* *ahem* Hi...uh...got a little to inot that...great job _
MadFearow 7/10/01 . chapter 1
Good job! I like how you portrayed the friendship between Growlithe and James.
Wild Growlithe 7/10/01 . chapter 1
::sniffle:: How sad! Poor little puppy! I love stories about James and Growlie. James really should have taken him with him. This is a great way of expressing how Growlie must have felt when James left him for the second time. I hope one day he comes back for him!
Snow7 7/10/01 . chapter 1
Soooo saddddd - sniff**

makes me wanna write a story about James going back home and taking Growlie with him!
Shadsie 7/9/01 . chapter 1
Whoa! Love it! Poor Growlie!
Alicorn 7/9/01 . chapter 1
Ahhhhh...I MISS JAMES;.;! WAAAAAAAA!..Wait, he did'nt really die..that was just his made up story...poor Growlie ;.;
Return to Top