Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: A Noble Obligation - Page 1 of 17
Lynn-G
2007-11-12 . chapter 9
I just wanted to ask on which story Dean gets his ring?
karmasnape
2007-06-06 . chapter 9
i love the list. i also wanted this list, it will make things a lot easier, i have been trying to get them in order but was not succeding. i love the brotherhood and the stories. i did notice however that in your list there was no mention of the story 'what moms do'. i remember reading it and then a mention of the cave in another brotherhood story.

also could you let us know which author each story is under? if it is alright i am planning on printing them all and putting them in ordr in a folder, it makes them easier to read.

thank you all for the wonderful universe.

karmasnape
River City1
2007-05-23 . chapter 9
Wow! Thanks for the Q & A section! The story was neat too. I likeed the touch of Dean finding the new engraving on the ring.
cavetrollgrl
2007-05-22 . chapter 9
loved the story kept readers on the edge of their seats. Thanks for the question and answers a lot of questions were answered can't wait for your next story.
Berserker Nightwitch
2007-05-22 . chapter 9
This is a great story! Poor Dean. Seeing his father and then having it all be a dream... I really enjoyed reading this.

I do have one thing to point out, though. I think Caleb is actually portrayed by Victor Webster, not Webber. Just in case it ever becomes an issue, it was Webster who played in Must Love Dogs and the others. Just thought you might like to know.

Once again, I really liked this, and can't wait to read any sequels/other stories in this AU.
Wysawyg
2007-05-21 . chapter 9
Love the summary of the timeline and all the little hints of stories to come! Looking forward to when they get written.

You ever thinking of a follow-up to Tecumseh and Dogtown? I admit Dean-with-powers is something I really love reading and I loved your twist on it.

Thanks for all the answers.
Lilly B.
2007-05-21 . chapter 9
thank you tidia and ridley for the brotherhood summary, timeline and for answering all the questioins that you did. it was really helpful to us readers to get a sense of where everything fits into place. sometimes it's hard to keep track of things when there are so many fics involoved, and you all do such a great job of keeping us entertained with fic after fic. you do an exceptional job on this brotherhood and i can't wait for the future stories you have planned. thanks again!
GuestTypePerson
2007-05-21 . chapter 8
interesting. lady of the lake. intersting turn. i look forward to see where this is all going.
Eve2006
2007-05-20 . chapter 9
Just want to say thanks the summary and the questions and answer section - I love the Brotherhood stories. Keep up the good work.
sams1ra
2007-05-20 . chapter 9
Thank you guys for the chronological list, and thanks for the q&a, but it only gave me more questions ;)

"The pastor recognized an opportunity-a moment of chance he could not let slip through his fingers." Which story is this from? Was it written, and if not, will it be?

"It seemed fitting that he bring the two together to let John mentor the boy." ditto

"Jim sent Mackland Ames to coach John Winchester in the ways of The Brotherhood and despite their diverse backgrounds the men found common footing in their dedication to the fight. So much so that Jim as The Guardian chose Mackland to be The Scholar and John to be the Knight." ditto.

"He began to prepare the next generation's Triad—Sam as The Scholar, Caleb as The Knight and Dean as The Guardian-in one possible scenario." why? I still don't get it. at that young an age (Sam was what, 2?) why was Sam chosen as scholar and Dean as guardian? how'd they know the kids will grow into these parts? Was it really just a selfish act on John's part? And if it were, why didn't Mac and Jim protest?

One of the stories mentions scouts coming to see Dean play baseball and the possibility for him to play in college. Will we get to read the story? (careful, new stories make new bunnies ;) )
Are we gonna find out more about Jim's background?
Glad to see there are more Brotherhood stories in the works. I love these stories, and I hope you pass that along to Ridley!
SilverStorm06
2007-05-19 . chapter 9
You guys are truly awesome for coming up with such a wildly popular idea, the Brotherhood. :)
Mishka89
2007-05-19 . chapter 9
Thanks a bunch for answering the questions. I really enjoyed reading this little thing, got some wicked insight to places I was confused in. Looking forward to more in The Brotherhood AU. You girls rock!
Becomingwhaturmeantobe
2007-05-19 . chapter 8
I loved that. It was great. John being back shocked me, and I love the twist on it. I also read the summary and answers for the Brotherhood AU, thanks for that! It clears a lot up and I am looking forward to reading whatever you guys write next!
bLEWfire
2007-05-19 . chapter 8
Alright girl, here I am - FINALLY - now that I've had a chance to catch up. I'm loving this story. The John/dream bit threw me a little but now I've got it and I liked that twist. Though I have to wonder if that was the plan all along.

Anywho, I'm liking the progression of the story and you can let Rid know that I'm eagerly awaiting her next story (which I assume by the title involves Victor Stephens the former scholar) and also the Bhood's reaction to the events of ABHL 1&2. Nice work and please keep it up.

... haha - I just realized chapter 8 was the end. Now that I think about it it makes a good ending - I just was so used to being behind... lol.

Anyways, I'm bummed I missed the question and answer bit - but I'll go read them now and maybe all my ?s got answered.

btw - if you get a chance, will you check out my oneshot "In the Still of the Night"? I asked Will and Rid awhile ago, but forgot to ask you. Thanks!
Ash8
2007-05-19 . chapter 9
Thanks for all those answers - even though I didn't ask any questions I found the information here fascinating.

Interestingly enough, I just re read Heroes and I loved it but could tell it was an early Brotherhood story, as the characters have developed so much more since then. I will be eager to read the re write. Heroes and The Line I think are up there as my favourite Brotherhood stories - oh and the Dragon series, oh and the one when Mac visits Sam at college. Thanks for all the stories and can't wait for the new ones!!
Return to Top