Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Fairy Tale Variation: The little mermaid - Page 1 of 11
burichifan
2009-11-06 . chapter 11
hm...nothing better than lovers eternal...the story wasn't that complex for my taste...but still nice...
EleCoR
2009-07-22 . chapter 11
I love your creations to no end.. Just when I thought I had cracked the secrets of your plot I find myself moments later in disbelief and giving out a somewhat loud "what!?".. I believe it is what gives your stories that sort of addictive and wonderful quality..
Nai89
2009-06-29 . chapter 11
A very lovely story ^_^
Konson
2008-12-02 . chapter 1
I love this story. It was really awesome! Keep doing these kind of stories!
markesellus
2008-09-30 . chapter 11
So another great and exciting story by you. Personally I really liked the whole mermaid concept, I kind of wish there was more of it. In my mind I kind of envisioned Himeko to be the curious mermaid that saved Chikane, but this way works really well. Great story, very amusing and heartwarming.
DezoPenguin
2008-07-27 . chapter 11
Well! I'm quite surprised to say that I enjoyed this story very much. I tend to dislike AU fics, because all too often the transition to another setting, another background strips out the essential nature of the characters, making them OCs that happen to have the names of a particular canon.

This fic does not do that. It does a nice job of preserving several of the basic elements of KnM (the star-crossed love between Chikane and Himeko, the personalities of the leads, the conflict between Orochi and the world, and the burden of destiny placed on them by past lives), while transitioning them into the "Little Mermaid" fairytale. I must admit that I would have expected Chikane to be the princess, but after considering it your casting choice makes more sense--the mermaid is the active initiator of events in the fairytale, and Himeko has to learn to break out of her passivity. Chikane is obviously considerably less tormented than her KnM model is, but that follows because the past-life burdens placed upon her are considerably different.

On the down side, there are a couple of places where Makoto's actions don't always seem to make sense (especially where it concerns Chikane and Himeko's relationship, she seems to attribute more knowledge to Chikane than Chikane actually possesses), and the other seven Sages' personalities seem to exaggerate drastically towards good or evil (Korona and Reiko on one side; Tsubasa, Girochi, Miyako, Souma, and Nekoko the other way) which actually strips them of some of their complexity from the original series (well, okay, Tsubasa, Souma, and Miyako...I'm not going to call Girochi and Nekoko "complex"!!).

Conversely, I like what you've done with Otoha and Kazuki, and several of the original characters (the kitchen staff, the gardener, and the steward were especially nice), and Makoto's final chapter actions were the kind of thing that came out of left field when I read it, whereupon I immediately started kicking myself because you'd set it up so I should have seen it coming).

One question--in the epilogue you mention that the remaining "Four" Sages had retreated into seclusion, but shouldn't there be five? Or have I somehow missed a line where one of them was killed and I'm just sounding silly?
yui1808
2008-07-14 . chapter 11
wow, that was something... i love how you deliver the story... say author, have you already tried publishing this? just change the main characters names' and you'll have your own story in a book... you are really great, do you know that? i am looking forward for your future stories... can you at least make a of ShizNat (Mai-hime/ Mai-otome), Shizuma X Nagisa (Strawberry Panic) too? well, a simple thank you is not enough to show you my gratitude but i hope you would likely feel how truly i appreciate your works for making this one and your other kannazuki no miko stories... i'm glad i get to read your works... till then... thank you...
tygeryoyo
2008-06-25 . chapter 11
Wow...that was ** amazing.
Brilliant plot, absolutely LOVED how you captured the emotions and conveyed unendingly lavish descriptions about everything.
Although it was a long read, hell, it was well worth it o.o
I am just astounded at how enrapturing this story is...just simply beautiful. Ah! I can't say enough praise ><
Everything was just spot-on and like...yeah. suhdi;ausgd
I love you =)
I will probably go on to read your other fanfics, and I am sure I won't be disappointed ;)
O.O
2008-04-16 . chapter 11
This story was just unbelievably fantastic! I pretty much never post comments after reading stories, but this outstanding work that you've crafted has drawn me out of my lurking ways. E, I've grown so obsessed with reading this wonderful fan fiction, - like most of the readers and reviewers here - that I couldn't stop thinking about what would happen in the next chapter during school. Gah, I absolutely love your writing, keep at it!
Maxmilian
2008-04-03 . chapter 11
I'm really moved with this fic.
It was really beautiful.
As your other two fics it was simply amazing to read.
U're definitely my favourite author out there.
It helps a lot that U write about Chikane/Himeko which I love greatly ^_^.

I just noticed that message U sent to Aloneness. Her name was really familliar so I looked it up.
And I found that she was writing Capturing a Heart (so thats where I knew her from) which I was really loonking forward to read. As she hasnt updated in a while.
It's really sad at to what she has done. It's really awful. I mean it could be ok with permission from the original author (which is U in this case) but doing it without permission and taking credit for someone else's work just isn't fair. But I sincerely hope U can come up with a sollution. I like her work wery much too. And doing this kind of bad bussines concerning Chikane/Himeko pains me a lot.

So again thank U far sharing your beautiful stories with us. Seeing as U've updated your profile recently it means U're alive.
I'm looking forward to hearing from U soon.
Your faithfull reader...
Gurutiro
2008-03-16 . chapter 11
I'm utterly amazed at the language you used and how you developed the story of the two lovers. What was really good was the fact that you concentrated on the other aspects of the story rather than only on Himeko and Chikane. I was astonished by how emotional the story was, I actually cried ^_^! You have my thumbs up, keep writing, you have great talent ;)
Linnara
2008-03-10 . chapter 11
You write some of the best stories I ever was able to read on the internet - really excellent work. :-)
dragonginnygrl
2008-02-27 . chapter 11
yay! that was so cute! what happened to Mako-chan though?
Aloneness
2007-12-27 . chapter 11
This story's unbelievable and amazing. This is probably my most favorite work of yours. ~Aloneness
Tuume
2007-11-16 . chapter 4
Your wrting is exquisite and structured. I could never write a chapter this long. What's your secret?
Return to Top