Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: As Lovers Go
tanith-4486
2008-12-30 . chapter 1
nice. sad, bitter yet happy. very nice.
Frayed Misfit
2007-09-06 . chapter 1
I really do love your work, the brevity and emotion of this line was perfect: "Twelve years later, they’re reunited, and in the moment of their embrace, there’s an unspoken promise between them; each forgives the other without words."

Thank you for another wonderful read.

- Frayed
truthsetfree
2007-07-23 . chapter 1
Normally, I avoid anything that even implies Remus/Tonks just on principle, but...

I found this very well written, and very real. Well done.
SweetSouthernGal
2007-05-20 . chapter 1
I love Dashboard, and this song. And this story.
ih8writersblock
2007-05-06 . chapter 1
congradulations to you, you're officially the first hp story i have reviewed (and found worth reviewing) i loved it! beautifully written, and the end bit was hilarious. i love this pairing, they're so perfect for eachother (sirius is NOT dead!) i look foreward to reading more of your work.
Prieda Solo
2007-05-02 . chapter 1
Another beautiful piece of writing. Remus is (i think) slightly OOC in the first section (the shouting part really) but it can be understood, he's gone through a lot.

Other than that a great great story. And I've just got the sirius=star thing too :) Moonstar-so cute.

Very sad ending. Especially as we know whats coming for sirius :-(
Lexie-H
2007-04-17 . chapter 1
even though i really dont support remus and sirius as a pairing, i think you've done a wonderful job! you convey emotion beautifully, and i love that you finished it with a sense of humour too! i think maybe this is quite different from other stuff that you've done, and i just want to congratulate you on experimenting and coming up with come wonderful results! xx - Lexie
Kind Of Catchy
2007-04-16 . chapter 1
wow...that didn't sound like you at all. lovely, despite the fact that they're still not my pairing! very well written, nice descriptions and fun stuff like that! sirius is a bit of a man ** isn't he...lol. in the words of pepperd "its good especially the profanity" (or something to that effect)i've never heard that song before...and on that note i leave you, goodbye!
much luv
~hplover~

2007-04-15 . chapter 1
That's a pretty cool story...
The Masked Nightmare
2007-04-15 . chapter 1
Okay so, your story started out REALLY well ritten and beautifully detailed but as you went the quality slipped slightly. Not to say, however, that the story is bad. I atually liked it very much.
NickyFox13
2007-04-15 . chapter 1
My god, this was wonderful. It was beautifully sad, but still breathtaking and just amazingly written.
rekahneko
2007-04-15 . chapter 1
A wonderful song and a wonderful story to go with it!
I especially liked how you made it so clear how much they love each other without either one of them actually saying, "I love you."
(-:
sweets555
2007-04-15 . chapter 1
love it! especially since i love dashboard confessional...so the title was mostly what made me read it.
it was a great story, keep it up!
StarfireFowl
2007-04-15 . chapter 1
That was a gorgeous fic. Totally different from the rest of yours style-wise. (Seeing as how the rest don't say "**" in them.) *is very impressed* Loved it. (And I didn't actually know that Dashboard song, so I decided to listen to "Hands Down" while reading this. I probably should go listen to the song this is based on though.)
Return to Top