Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Recall Alice When She Was Just Small - Page 1 of 34
alokin
2009-10-25 . chapter 30
BTW

The title of the fic is "Recall Alice When She Was Just Small" , but who in the hell is Alice ?

Is it , like , some generic title ? No special meaning ?
alokin
2009-10-25 . chapter 31
ABSOLUTELY FUCKING BRILLIANT !

I was thinking about saying something fancy and stuff , but fuck that !


Ive been reading this 7 hours straight and its AMAZIING !

How did you stay so perfectly in canon ? HOW ? I cant understand it !!

This is absolutely how I imagined Dudley to be like !

No offense , but forget all your other fanfics cause this one is your
MASTERPIECE !!
Red Avarice
2009-09-02 . chapter 31
Now these sort of stories are the reason that I haven't been working on my own fiction. Well, that and influenza.

This has to be one of the best stories I have ever read. A review from me is very rare and this story was amazing the whole way through. Dudley has always interested me and seeing things from his perspective rather than from Harry's is something I have always wanted.

Thank you for this amazing piece of writing.

By the way, "Red Avarice" really is my account name...
Twinnie
2009-07-23 . chapter 31
Clever, realistic, extremely well-thought and well-constructed. Your work is much more reminiscent of a character study than it is of a Harry Potter fic.

I truly enjoyed reading this. Thank you ^.^
Cap'n BlackRose
2009-07-18 . chapter 31
so, i must say, this was amazing.
i usually think of dudley as just some nasty little child that rowling cooked up as a childhood terror for harry. but you really did something here, all the while keeping this amazingly realistic!
great job!
Cheers!
The Cap'n
Fire From Above
2009-07-18 . chapter 31
I really like the way that Dudley's life has turned out. Heh, he went to Grunnings anyway. It was great to see things not turn out all happily ever after with everyone getting on good terms, but in a realistic way. Thank you so much for the time and effort you put into this story. I had a lot of fun reading it, even though I had to wait a while to finish it.
Fire From Above
2009-07-18 . chapter 30
You did a good job with that bit of awkwardness of reunion. It would be interesting to see another get together between those two.
Fire From Above
2009-07-17 . chapter 29
I really enjoyed Dudley's struggles to find his place. It was great to see him out in the real world trying to take care of himself. It was also nice to see what has happened to some other people. I like his bouncer job.
Fire From Above
2009-07-17 . chapter 28
It took 2 years for DH to come out in paperback, which is why I am finishing the story just now. I really like how Dudley has changed and grown up, especially in this chapter. He isn't the most eloquent person, but he knew what the truth was and was able to come to terms with how he was raised.
Kairithelostsoul
2009-07-13 . chapter 31
I rarely review, but I feel I must express my opinion on this wonderful bit of fanfiction. I have to admit when I began reading this story I thought it dragged on a bit, but as the chapters kept going I was sucked into the life of Dudley Dursley, a character who, in my opinion is too often overlooked. I imagine your portrayal is quite like what JK Rowling would have written had she gone into more detail on Dudley's life, and I applaud you. My favorite stories list had earned a new fic.
Elena Kansi
2009-06-20 . chapter 31
That was the best Dudley story I have ever read.

I think you represented him very well, and had realistic character growth.
vincent1875
2009-05-30 . chapter 31
Great story. Sad to see it end. Funny, dramatic, and eye catching.
vincent1875
2009-05-28 . chapter 2
Great story so far. Dudley's pretty funny.
WorldOfLilyEvans
2009-05-06 . chapter 31
I loved this story! I wanted to read a story that was about Dudley, for once, and this one was precisely what I was looking for!

Maybe I'll read it's twin now!

-x- Malou
Attila's Wife
2009-04-14 . chapter 31
not exactly a happy story huh? still, i liked it for the most part.
Return to Top