Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Help
Reviews For: Marvin Meet Lilly - Reviews: Page 1 of 3
The Toon Geekette 2008-11-07 . chapter 1
I hope you're one of those authors who don't mind some negative criticism, because I just don't like this fic.

First off, the character of Lilly. Okay, there's no nicer way to put it, she's a Mary Sue. Tragic backstory, everyone good loves her by the end, amazingly talented, she falls in love with a character the author likes...you see where I'm going with this? Not only that, but I feel she's a little out-of-place in the Looney Tunes/Duck Dodgers-verse. Her tragic backstory seems a bit too dramatic for the tone of either the original shorts or the TV show (come to think of it, I think, that kind of backstory would be parodied more often than it would be played straight in either one). In fact, let's be honest, Lilly isn't very funny, as her attempts at being funny fall kind of flat, which is kind of weird for a fic taking place in the cartoon universe that gave us the funniest cartoon shorts of all time.

Now that I'm done with that, here's another point that bothers me - the characterization of Marvin. Now, granted, I just got into Duck Dodgers by watching episodes on streaming video sites, but Marvin doesn't seem the type to act like this when it comes to romance. You have him acting like a shy preteen boy trying to ask a girl to the dance. Watch any episode of Duck Dodgers, or any Looney Tunes short with Marvin in it, then compare that to the way you wrote him.

There's also some minor spelling errors. Run this through a word processing program first (like Microsoft Word), and spell check it. After that, proofread it again, because even spell check can be wrong.

Sorry that review ended up a little long, but I just had to say it. Keep these tips in mind for any future fanfiction you write, or even original fiction.
Carlint 2008-08-03 . chapter 1
Hiya! It's me again! I have a question & to tell you: I'm reading it again for the FOURTH time! Ok, my question is... well, I've wondered for awhile since I read this, if this were a movie, would Lilly be realistic in the real world like in an adult movie or, would she be like a cartoon? And, I've wanted to say this on chapter 9 for a long time:

When Lilly said "This just screams SERIES!", I totally agree! It does scream series! And, you know what else it screams? It screams THE MOST FABULOUS FAN FIC EVER! I WANT TO SEE IT ON TV OR DVD! I may have told you that before, but, I can't stop telling you how awesome it is! It makes me feel so fuzzy inside when I really think about them!

Also, I also wanted to say that I was very surprised when you said you got to go to California on the Warner Brothers Tour! I want to go so bad! I want X-2 merchandise, too & for the record, I never noticed you said that you've wanted to write it for a year! You must have had a lot of thinking time to make it so INCREDIBLE! And, I also LOVE Marvin/X-2!

Enough said for now. I might save my other reviews for the next time I read this whole story for the fifth time!
Carlint 2008-07-26 . chapter 8
I've always loved this chapter! I'm going to read the last one, which is, OF COURSE, my FAVORITE! Although, it goes very well with the rest of the movie to make it one SPECTACULAR movie!
Carlint 2008-07-26 . chapter 7
Hiya! It's me, AGAIN! I was gonna review, but, now, I forgot what I was going to say... AHAH! I remember, now! I read the top, too. Where it says: I'm am all warm & fuzzy inside... I feel the same way! See ya'! Hope you've liked my reviews so far!
Carlint 2008-07-26 . chapter 6
I'm guessing Read & Review is what R & R stands for, yes?Well, another chapter to "Marvin Meet Lilly", read for the thrid time! Bye!
Carlint 2008-07-26 . chapter 5
I love that song!! I've decided that I'm going to do another Season 1 episode of Marvin & Lilly for my next fic & THEN my Y/DD Fan Fic! I've been dying to do it! I may need a better name, though. Maybe you can help? I'm thinking maybe... well, now, I can't remember... tee hee! Sorry! I'll try & rememeber in ym next fic that Lilly doesn't say "Tee hee". ^-^ So, I have one more question... when do you think you'll finish "Lilly's Fame" & maybe start another fan fic? I LOVE you're stories SO much! I wish they were on TV SO bad! Did I ever tell you that? Well, see ya in the next chapter if it let's me review. I can't remember which one's I reviewd on already... except I keep trying to review the last chapter, but, I've already reviewed. ^-^ Oh, one more thing: I'll give you he plot to my next fic of Marvin & Lilly so you can help to think of a name.

Plot: Marvin is kidknapped in the middle of the night by evil beetles. He wakes up to find himself in a cage & later, he ends up almost killed by scorpions. Lilly saves him just in time, only to splatter more goo on him & Dr. Woe. Little do Marvin & Lilly know, that the goo is poisonous to Martians. It starts to appear as if to boil & starts burning. Lilly manages to get it off & they take it to the ship in a jar for experimenting. The next night, it emerges to a giant goo beetle. Oh GREAT! MORE BUGS! ^^

I haven't thought of... quite how they stop it, because, it is invincible to gun shots. Not sure yet. Maybe heat. Yeah, that's good. So, what do you think? Any ideas? You can take you're time answering this so you can think of one before you answer me. Thanks! I hope you like long reviews!
Carlint 2008-07-26 . chapter 4
HI! It's me again! I'm reading your TOTALLY AWESOMESAUCE story for the THIRD TIME! It's so totally ROCKING AWESOME! I just HAD to read it AGAIN! Glad you've liked my stories so far, too! I love this chapter! I always have! It's so funny! You're the most awesomesauce novilist I know! I learned Awesomesauce form my friend, Mansay from DeviantART, or DA, as we call it for short. If you have an account, there, you're very, very welcome to note me. My profile is: http://carlint./ Well, that's about it! OH! And, I almost forgot! I love both the songs you put in here! I'm listening to Girlfriend right now & I've been listening to For Good all day! Sorry if it takes you a long time to answer this. My next fic will be up soon. I'm gonna draw more Marvin & Lilly Fan Art, now. I'll put it on DA for you to see. OH! And, maybe, you could fill in the first ever "Marvin & Lilly" Meme! I made it in honor of Marvin & Lilly! Well, I'll see you later! Time to read chapter 5 & all the rest! Oh, & maybe episode 1 & 2 again &...

X-2: LILLY!

LOL! Bye!
Carlint 2008-07-03 . chapter 2
Hi! This chapter was great! the Tv idea was one of the things that made this movie so totally FABULOUS!! Tee hee!

Dodgers: See you there, bucket head!

That's funny! LOL! I love this whole movie!! I've read it & episodes 1 & 2 twice now! That's right, TWICE!! Tee hee! Well, bye! hope you liked my review!
Carlint 2008-07-01 . chapter 9
Hi! This was the BEST movie EVER! Well, I think, even though there's already a series, that your series rocks! I can't wait to see part 2 of episode 3!! I love them all! I've read all your duck Dodgers stories in one day & I love Them! I also have an account on & I like it there, too! I'm new here, so, for now, I'll just review, then when i can, I'll submit my two stories from . Anyways, I loved all your stories! there better than mine!! I think that Lilly is adorable! I learned how she looked on deviantart & I'll draw some pics of her, too! I'm also friends with the person who drew the ones you've seen. And I love them! Hoep to see part 2, soon1 Keep up the good work! I love the couple! Check out my ID on deviantart! It's not up, yet, but when I'm done, it'll say "MArvinxLilly 4Ever!" I love the couple! and Lilly is funny & cute!! Well, see ya'!
shadowluigi243 2008-07-01 . chapter 8
y should really make this one a series and do u mind if i can copy this on Deviantart?
Grogie13 2008-06-22 . chapter 9
I'm probably VERY late for this but YES it should be a series! And if it's already a series then GO YOU!

So very cute! And sheesh, lady, you come up with better plotlines than I can. COOKIE FOR JOO! *hands NBCF a plate of magical cookies that turn into whatever kind you like* *Grogie13 whips out her own plate and munches happily on peanut butter cookiez and sugar cookiez*

I'm ssoo-oo-oo-oo-oo checking out your other Looney Tunes fics... if you have any more... YEAH!

~Groigie13~
shadowluigi243 2008-06-22 . chapter 9
thats is the coolest story i have ever read! hope u make another story i really enjoyed this one. ^^
justformusic 2008-05-02 . chapter 9
Wow, this is a late review, but I just stumbled upon your story. I have to say that I love how you incorporated both Wicked (so, so much love for that! One of my favorite musicals!) and even Phantom of the Opera into the story! I also really enjoy your writing style :) Please keep writing, I am excited to read more about the adventures these two will go through!
tomboyishgirl108 2008-01-16 . chapter 9
Awesome story, girl! :D Marvin the Martian is my favorite character from Looney Tunes too! :)
Pagiki Higgins 2007-12-27 . chapter 9
I say YES! sorry for jumping out of the blue like this but I totally forgot that I was logged in until I read this chapter! xD I'm still new though. lol!
Return to Top