|Reviews for Might Have Beens|
| 5SecstoThrowItFB 12/25/12 . chapter 9
All these serious ones, and 6 still casting a shadow over my heart... And then this! AHAHAHAHA! Iy's perfect, and so, so funny! (Add epilogue: Frodo laughing evilly/hysterically with Sam and Bilbo and Boromir and Merry and Pippin and everyone!)
| Tonnocal 11/26/12 . chapter 9
...carols. with dark lords...totally headcanon now
| Virtuella 1/3/11 . chapter 9
How utterly bizarre, and yet strangely plausible!
| L.A.H.H 1/2/11 . chapter 9
Festive! And excellent. Thanks for writing. x
| Anicularum lucubrationes 12/30/10 . chapter 6
ugh. the chapter was very well written and lovely in a sense, but it made me cringe and feel very sad. Poor Frodo imprisoned the one that claimed to love him, wasting away. Sam was being downright selfish by not letting Frodo go across the sea to get the healing he needed. good job.
| Emily 12/14/09 . chapter 6
That outcome is really not something I wish to think about. The spider in the neck thing was inspired, but gross.
Thankfully, Sam loved Frodo too much to do this to him. : )
| Emily 12/14/09 . chapter 5
Drat Gollum. : (
| Emily 12/14/09 . chapter 3
I believe you named this chapter most aptly. Most unexpected, indeed.
| Emily 12/14/09 . chapter 2
While I was not totally adverse to the idea of the first might-have-been (I know, I know, I'm being awfully mean to Frodo, aren't I?), this one I absolutely do not like.
| Virtuella 11/17/09 . chapter 8
Aha, yes, and one must wonder if Gandalf the /Grey/ would have been up to the challenges ahead!
| Virtuella 5/19/09 . chapter 7
Yes, that fits in seamlessly. I like this idea of fixing the movies!
| Tracey Claybon 1/30/09 . chapter 6
An interesting - and somewhat chilling - twist on the aftermath... I like it, but it did leave me chilled.
| Alaenor JS-XIII 5/18/08 . chapter 5
Ew. Semi-cannibalism. That is what would have happened, though. And then I suppose some orc would eventually get It. Poor Bilbo, though! That's so gruesome! *shudders and puts down her ham sandwich*
| Alaenor JS-XIII 5/18/08 . chapter 1
I'm so glad Sam gets to be badass for once! He's such a strong character, but he's stuck in the supporting role, and he never really gets to spread his wings. I think it would be interesting to see what he could do. He certainly would have more sense when it came to Gollum, and I don't think he'd balk when it came down to actually destroying It. It's a very nice idea. If you don't ever continue it, my muse might force me to!
| szepilona10 3/30/08 . chapter 4
Interesting! You sould make one of the storys into a long one!