Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: A Matter of Taste - Page 1 of 4
White Wyrsa
2009-09-03 . chapter 9
Fabulous story! Done in best traditions but with much more action. Real jewel! Thank you for great pleasure!
White Wyrsa
2009-09-03 . chapter 3
OH! Great I was wrong about elder Holmes! Very nice chapter, good work!
White Wyrsa
2009-09-03 . chapter 2
Very good story so far - intriguing and very "Doylish" plot, interesting characters. So curious what happens next! Very much hope no harm will be done to Cavennesses. And hope Mycroft has nothing to do with this, dear me. Can't actually believe it's to his taste...there is allways other way.
FoggyKnight
2008-08-30 . chapter 9
Woot! I wonder if Queen Victoria heard about Sherlock's decorative piece in Mrs. Hudson's walls.

Nice speech Mycroft. ^^

Great story!
FoggyKnight
2008-08-30 . chapter 7
Good old Lestrade :). Now let's see what two old militaristic brains can cook up. :) On to the next chapter!
FoggyKnight
2008-08-30 . chapter 5
*growls* That imbecile. Wonder what it is he's trying to hide besides the bomb. Poor Lestrade. Poor Watson.
smallrose
2008-04-12 . chapter 4
"One must not sacrifice the justice of the moment for the consequences of the future." - this is a brilliant line.
Protector of the Gray Fortress
2008-02-12 . chapter 9
Wot! Go Mycroft!
oh VH you have surpassed yourself. I've never properly read one of your stories before this but your marvelous reviews pressed me into it.
You have created an excellent villain in the person of Hollingworth, he carries all the vices and traits of the impossible aristocracy that Holmes was able to oppose from time to time. Such a villain was rarely seen in the canon and I am thrilled that you have pulled it off here so nicely!
You're Watson, Mycroft and especially Your Holmes were most certainly in character and the aid of Lestrade and esp Mycroft were wonderful surprises.
I intend to raed your other stories as well so this is not the end of my reviewing.
You have pulled off an aweinspiring story that has a true ring of the origional canon and your own special touch as well.
thank you so much for sharing your talents...they amaze me no end.
Well done!
-PGF
Amelia McDermid
2007-11-29 . chapter 9
I liked this one

great story
Saru Wolfe
2007-10-14 . chapter 9
There is very little I can say here that I haven't said before.

Mycroft was also in character. It was great that he came around. Endings always work better that way. Oh, and the plot on this one was excellent, as well.

The one and only thing that I don't like has to do with format. The chapters are a wee bit on the short side (and not such a wee bit in the sequel). That's all. Carry on.

Great job!

~Saru Wolfe
Locky's Princess
2007-09-22 . chapter 9
awsome, sweet,col. totally
silberklang
2007-08-07 . chapter 9
Well done, my dear Watson! It could not be more splendidly written. I believe I foresee a sequel coming on, though...The game is afoot!
SherlockianGirl
2007-07-12 . chapter 9
wow wow wow wow wow wow wow wow wow wow wow wow wow wow wow wow wow. That was GREAT! Just got your email saying there will be a sequel! YAY! I've been on the edge of my seat (alright, my recliner, lol) and I look forward to more! Sherlock fans unite! (ha ha, here's a fourth review! Sorry it took so long to read, been so busy...)
SherlockianGirl
2007-07-12 . chapter 6
You have captured (Sherlock) Holmes's laid back attitude and sarcasm extremely well! Kudos! I enjoy these brother to brother confrontations!
SherlockianGirl
2007-07-12 . chapter 5
OH MY GOODNESS! HOLMES ARRESTED?! Excellent turn of events! I just kind of sat there, staring at my computer screen, "in a stupefied state." Poor Watson, all on his lonesome. Ah, this is so much fun!
Return to Top