Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Brown Eyed Girl

Ladyhawke 620
2008-06-04
ch 2,
abuseEnjoyed the update. It gives nice motivation into what led to Ellie hunting String down later to talk to him. I still think part one's "lot's of beautiful kids line" is the best though. It still remains romantic and tragic to the end. Sweet but sad. Guess we all have our regrets.
Enfleurage
2008-06-02
ch 2,
abuseDidn't read the 1st chapter when it was first posted because I'm so not a St. John fan (Barry VD just wasn't right for the show, but I digress).

Read it this time around and was blown away at how well you conveyed how *young* String is, not in an immature or silly way, but a realistic sense of inexperience and bad choices made because he doesn't know better yet, not because he's so hardened it doesn't matter.

I actually *liked* St. John in this story, much to my surprise, probably because he was more fully realized as a character and more interesting than the S4 version.

And an OC that was interesting, believable, and intriguing. I am curious for more.
Bethhawke
2008-06-02
ch 2,
abuseYou have a real talent for reading between the lines and making a TV episode into a full blown story.
Ladyhawke 620
2008-05-30
ch 1,
abuseBeautiful flashback. It's been awhile since I first read it. It was wellworth reading again.
Bethhawke
2008-05-24
ch 1,
abuseThis is my second favourite of your fanfics ('The Lady' being the first). I never paid much attention to the flashbacks in HX1 until I read this, then I had to watch it again! Excellent.
SithelfJen
2007-07-05
ch 1,
abuseA very nice lost scene for HX1.
Thanks for posting
Cassandra30
2007-06-11
ch 1,
abuseAbsolutely!! They still can. It's not too late when he got back.
rainefan
2007-05-09
ch 1,
abuseVery nice. You've added a lot of depth to one of my favourite scenes in the series.
CindyB
2007-05-07
ch 1,
abuseVery cool. I liked this Saint John way better than the Barry Van ** version that came later.
The Fink
2007-05-07
ch 1,
abuseOh; very nice. HX-1 is possibly one of my favourite episodes out of the whole show and you've fleshed it out beautifully.

Thank you :)
Rachel500
2007-05-06
ch 1,
abuseGreat start! I love String's introspection. Very well written. Can't wait for the rest. :)
Return to Top