Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: A Square Peg in a Round Hole - Page 1 of 29
nljfs
2009-11-07 . chapter 13
As always, another great story! You are definitely heading straight to the top of my favorite authors list!

nancy in chicago
graydevilforever
2009-10-20 . chapter 13
I love to death that you turned Methos into a god!! He He !! Theres not many stories where I have an ending that fits perfectly. I sorta long for a sequal but I sence that it would suck unless it was a drabble. In other words I love your ending. sQE.
Graydevilforever
mountainelements
2009-10-18 . chapter 3
"His voice held a faint accent that was really the mishmash of accents more common to older immortals than to mortals. It made him seem more dangerous to Methos." I have to wonder what would happen if any Immortals met Daniel while searching for Methos at the SGC. Would any Immortal be unstable/desperate enough to assume that Daniel is Methos, based on his accent, and that he has managed to live so long because he figured out how to hide his quickening?

Also, I can't help but imagine Methos having a plan for Immortals being discovered. Someone shows a video of an Immortal reviving but the video isn't clear enough evidence. Then Methos makes a phone call or tells someone else to make the phone call, and suddenly there's groups all over the world who believe in Immortals and try to convince others that they're real. Only Methos has made sure that most of the people are the sort that are easily dismissed and ignored, kind of like the reputations of people who claim that they were kidnapped by aliens. (I don't have any idea whether these people are correct or not, but I've noticed that they tend to be ridiculed and disbelieved by others in movies like Independence Day. No offense.) He also sets up a series of hoaxes about Immortals so that most people dismiss any true stories about them as well. I'm not really sure if he'd actually do this, as he has to know that the truth will come out some day, but maybe he's trying to buy time for something to happen first or hoping to get people used to the idea over time? Sorry. I know this part isn't really related to the story, but I've just wanted to share this idea for a while now so I can get it off my mind.
Frostfyre7
2009-10-10 . chapter 12
I really, truly, and deeply enjoyed this story. You took my favorite Highlander character and made him...become. It's a wonderful take on Methos, acknowledging both his vast age and the fact that the amusing, self-centered, beer-loving scholar truly is just an act, and that the real Methos is one scary powerful guy--not evil, merely...Death. I loved it! And Jake's journey as well, while not *quite* so profoundly explored, was nevertheless well thought out and believable. He's genuinely likable, and he really *isn't* Jack, whatever his five decades of shared memory might have confused him (and everyone else) with. The relationship between Jake and Methos was brilliantly done--touching, funny, and moving. Again, it was nice to see the "real" Methos here, capable of genuinely understanding and caring about the boy, and all the while manipulating him and everyone else for their own good and his amusement. Better yet, he accomplished all of this without actually "coming out" about Immortals to the SGC--which would have been an easy cop out. I like your approach so much better, with Methos taking their acceptance of alien 'gods' and getting them to believe, for now at least, in magic. No doubt someone in the SGC will eventually figure it out (though they're not going to get any help from the Watcher, I expect), but in the meantime, Methos has had his joke.

Thank you for a fantastic read!!
mountainelements
2009-10-01 . chapter 12
It's occurred to me that Methos' actions would have vast repercussions on the Game if most of the Immortals knew about them. I can't be positive but I suspect that the Immortal phenomenon only happens on Earth, or at least only on a very few planets, considering that Teal'c didn't seem to know of Immortals. So if a Gathering ever occurs, Methos might be out of reach of whatever pull it has. Plus, if the Prize really is to rule the Earth, Methos has already beaten it by gaining control of several worlds without even having to kill all the other Immortals.

So does Methos' absence mean that there never would be a Gathering? Immortals would have to consider whether there's a point to taking each other's heads, and whether they should try to kill Methos for "cheating" the Game. Some also might try to copy him or just try to get his power, even if the Gathering is merely a myth. Immortals could try to escape the Game by going to other worlds. It would be really chaotic at the SGC if many Immortals knew about Methos, as several Immortals would try to sneak through the Stargate or kill the new Immortal for more information.

Also, I've read some fics about how Watchers are concerned with who might win the prize and rule the world. How would the Watchers react to Methos' actions? Is he now "out of their jurisdiction"? Would they try to determine if he's suitable for ruling these other worlds? I don't think that they could really do much to stop him, but some Watchers are probably going to freak out, regardless of how logical it is. I both love and hate how your fics grab my attention and won't let it go.
mountainelements
2009-09-30 . chapter 13
I really, really enjoyed reading this story. It's a very good blend of these two worlds, and I have to wonder what happens afterwards.

I'm a bit confused about some things though, probably because all my information about Highlander comes from online and not from actually watching it. Methos was a Horseman from about 4 thousand years ago to 3 thousand years ago, correct? So Cassandra is about 3 thousand years old? That's what I had been thinking but I got a bit confused when reading this story so I'm not sure any more.

Also, do the Watchers know that Adam Pierson is Methos? I've recently read a couple of stories where the author mentions a Watchers CD that states the Watchers found out from Watching Cassandra. I'm not sure whether this applies to your story, as it hasn't to many of the stories I've read. I also can't help but imagine a series of revelations:
SG-There are more Immortals!
SG and Immortals-There's a secret society that spies on Immortals and is obsessed with history!
Immortals-Methos is real!
SG and Watchers-Adam Pierson was Methos and was hired to work on his own Chronicles!
Watchers (and Immortals to less surprise)-Aliens exist!
It's lots of fun to imagine it anyway.
Adri Methos Slytherin
2009-09-21 . chapter 13
Wow, I know others have said this but...sequel please!! Perhaps from the point of view of a rival system lord or one of Methos' Jaffa or perhaps from the viewpoint of a/the Tok'ra?? just to make it a bit different.
I love the dialogue, and also the psychology involved in the various interactions, most especially the insight into Teal'c. I have to admit I've read this story at least 10 times by now, it's one of my top 5 all time favourite fanfic stories.
FTFCHRIS
2009-09-09 . chapter 13
This story really needs a sequel. Hell it's dying for one.

Haven't really been into Highlander fanfics since the Seventh Dimension website went inactive but wish i came back to this genre sooner if people like you are still writing about Metho's. I can't stand Duncan and his hypocrisy.

Hope you continue this story in a sequel.
Reader in the Corner
2009-08-12 . chapter 8
"It took a while to figure out that he was somehow communicating in morse code in church Latin." Given that this is Daniel, talking about Methos, I really shouldn't have been surprised by something like that, but stil... That line is now one of absolute favorites. The incongruity is just too perfect.
Deritine
2009-08-01 . chapter 13
Wow, this is really really good. You made it match up in such an interesting and pleasing way. I freaking love Mathos, and who doesn't squee with pleasure at gods and super powerful beings and sword fights? I was so enamored of this story I got really really cranky when people interrupted me from reading it. Even when one of those interruptions was a delicious lobster dinner! Great job!
Dark Archer
2009-07-14 . chapter 11
Nice. Poor Methos though.
Dark Archer
2009-07-14 . chapter 8
This is a really great story, is there a sequeal? Please say there is. Methos and Jake are great together. What would happen when that pre immortal dies? If it woould be in Jake's lifetime, he would be pletnty jelous of whoever it was.( hint* good story idea there*)
Ebon Hush
2009-07-06 . chapter 13
Oh, my God. This was made of pure awesome. It reminded me somewhat of another story/series called 'changing of the guard'; have you read that? It's also a crossover with SG-1. I heartily recomend it. It can be found on seventh-dimension. I loved this piece of work and thought it very clever and interesting. I've added it to my favourites and will definitely be reading it again. Have you considered doing a sequel?

I'd really like to read that if you do (since I've not yet found a good Methos/SGA crossover; I'm more of an Atlantis person, really). I am scuttling off to see if you've written anything else.

Thanks for sharing.

Ebon Hush
ManicTater
2009-06-14 . chapter 12
I didn't even consider that Methos would make jake his First Prime :)
ManicTater
2009-06-14 . chapter 9
I can't get past that I want them to be loyal to the SGC and Earth.
Return to Top