Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Goodbye

iknowyour
2007-06-07
ch 1,
abuseGreat story. Kinda sad though.
wyldcat
2007-06-06
ch 1,
abuseVery well written! Could've been part of the ep :D I like the points you made about Smith being a part of the Doctor - you know, that bit just before you switch to Joan's POV. Anyway. :D Good work!
Cute Gallifreyan
2007-06-05
ch 1,
abuseNice peice...makes sense that the Doctor would be in pain after it was painfull that particular change he went through.

Poor Joan. I think I feel sorry for her even more. After watching and rewatching the episode.

I added your story to my C2 and... thanks for the kind remarks on my story. I think FF is being glitchy because I tried to update earlier and the browser window glitched out on me. gr. It has to be said FF can be hell, when it wants to be.
Stefan the Vampire
2007-06-05
ch 1, anon.
abuseYeah, that gap needed filling.
Its Wonderful, great characterisation, really sounds like the Doctor: "'Ow,' he said, giving himself a little shake, 'Rewriting your entire biology twice in as many months really isn’t a good idea. ‘Course it isn’t recommended to try even once… but twice? – leaves you feeling tingly… and a little confused… where am I?'"
and I'm glad you added what Timothy said because that describes the Doctor really well.
Well done.
templremus1990
2007-06-05
ch 1,
abuseI have to say that I rather approached with the mentality of 'it's yet *another* post-Family of Blood fic'. However, you certainly dispelled all such doubts for me! Beautifully written and moving. Loved the bit about the Doctor/John Smith's eyes.
mrsreynolds
2007-06-05
ch 1, anon.
abuseI absolutely love this! It's so beautifully written. Didn't David Tennant break your heart in this eppie? I couldn't help feeling there was a hole left by this missing scene and you've done a perfect job of filling it. I'm kind of glad it wasn't there in the episode because I would have ended up crying my eyes out in front of my family!
Good luck with the exams! :)
Arwyn T
2007-06-05
ch 1,
abuseVery nicely written! It really feels like the scene we were never shown! Thank you!!
Return to Top