Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Under the Skin
Black Alya Wolf
2008-09-12 . chapter 1
I think I just about died when I read that "Reinette" was the cat...seriously, there's tears.

Great job! I love the ones with Rose and Martha that aren't Martha-bashing, and this one's original and...cool.
Terrifica Oneiroi
2008-06-26 . chapter 1
"Rose's words made her feel like she'd traveled with the Doctor herself." That is just brilliant! You sometimes look at certain characters and think: circumstances aside, would they get along? I often think that about Donna and Rose, and after watching "Turn Left", I think they would have, most definitely. (And I love how you've named their cat Reniette.) Great story, and as usuall... wonderful grammar!
Dizzy Hwin
2008-01-25 . chapter 1
Great little story. I'm so sick and tired of Rose VS Martha stories, I like how you've written the two characters to compliment each other.
blvdgirl
2007-09-16 . chapter 1
Delightful and plausible. It's lovely to think of Rose and Martha as friends.
Fusionmix
2007-09-11 . chapter 1
Your work really is fantastic, I must say. No grammatical errors, flawless characters, excellent plot...what more could a reader want? Oh, and cats name after French noblewomen. A balanced part of this breakfast.
AnimeAlexis
2007-07-29 . chapter 1
I like this. A lot, actually. It's kind of a cool thought that another Martha met Rose and liked her. With a guest appearance from the Doctor thrown in for fun, too! Very nice.
Leah's Lovely
2007-07-18 . chapter 1
Hahaha. Reinette the cat, love it. I would've made her a female dog, but there you go. Great story by the way, I'm looking forward to the next one you post.
Also, Seed Pearls was absolutely fabbity fab fab. I couldn't decide whether I'd rather Rose with the parralel sort-of ninth doctor or his tenth self, which meant that it must have been really really well written because usually I can't stand Rose not ending up with Ten after Doomsday.
I still live in hope that the BBC will come to their senses...
scullymulder
2007-06-07 . chapter 1
I absolutely love this. I can totally see, in this world, Rose and Martha being friends. You're an absolutely fantastic author -- which is very apparent, because you made me from being on the fence about Martha to liking her, lol.

Which baffles me, because all of the characters were perfect; as if they were really from the TV. (Rose's characterization was absolutely perfect.)

Wonderful job! I can't wait to read what you write next -- you always amaze me.
otahyoni
2007-06-06 . chapter 1
Aww. Love this! Martha and Rose would be a fabulous team.

Giggled at the tiny mention of Firefly having a season finale. Oh, to visit the Steel universe long enough to buy all the Firefly seasons on DVD! :)
x-EmilyTennant-x
2007-06-06 . chapter 1
hey that was really good :) i enjoyed it a lot
xheartxcorex
2007-06-06 . chapter 1
wow! this is amazing.
i loved it!
I really love the whole concept of Rose and Martha in each others heads.
good stuff
:) xx
Return to Top