Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: The New Girl - Page 1 of 9
qt4good
2008-06-21 . chapter 27
Wow!! I thought at first that a muggle had somehow come onto the platform, but it makes sense that she is a witch too..
And what a cliff-hanger at the end!
Overall, good story - will Draco's little sister finally learn how to do magic without blowing things up though? I wish she does!
Missy-Dedocakes
2008-04-27 . chapter 1
Hi :D
I have a limited schedule right now, not to mention I read slowly, so (and please don't get offended by this) I decided to read the reviewers comments on Evee besides the story. The reason for this, besides time, is because what the reviewer thinks about a story is often the most important. After all, it is them who authors try to impress, and as company people say "the costomer is always right"
You can hate me for choosing to do this, but I thought it would be a better way to see Evee.
Anyway, a lot of the stuff they were interested in was Evees relations with Ron and (it mentions) Seamus. This I don't really have a problem with, because a lot of people are in relationships that change and such and that can't classify someone as a Mary Sue.
Someone also mentioned she was a slut. They do wear uniforms at Hogwarts, so when you do rewrite it, you might want to change that.
As for family relations, if everyone with family relations to bad people was a Sue, Harry Potter would have people pissed off and protesting against him. So still good there, but don't overdo it.
The great thing is an overwhelming ammount of reviewers (even some of the flamers) really liked your plot. That's a talent and definitly keep that :D
Again, I'm sorry I couldn't read the story...
-MissD (TB Queen)
Paige
2008-01-10 . chapter 27
oh my gosh
hurry and write the
next one! I love it!
yeah I read the whole
thing in one day I couldnt
stop! it is so good.
if only you would have
writin harry potter first:]
luna
2007-12-28 . chapter 27
cliffhanger... write the sequel soon, please!
luna
2007-12-28 . chapter 25
so, she like called voldemort when she touched malfoy;s dark mark?

and charlie is her brother? this is getting confusing... but in a good way
luna
2007-12-28 . chapter 22
i don't know... i think i liked her better before she could do magic... but then i guess if she as a squib, there wouldn't be much to the story
luna
2007-12-28 . chapter 19
evee is seeming more... manipulating...
luna
2007-12-28 . chapter 17
cute snake
luna
2007-12-28 . chapter 16
:gasps: the SLUT! well, she's still ok, i guess
luna
2007-12-28 . chapter 14
i like charlie :)

and malfoy's sister, eh? that's a twist
luna
2007-12-28 . chapter 12
aw shit! voldemort killed her mum? why?
luna
2007-12-28 . chapter 11
o! and the plot thickens...
luna
2007-12-28 . chapter 10
they have remedial magic classes? well, i guess they'd have to if she wanted to stay there...
luna
2007-12-28 . chapter 9
hehehe.. ron and harry in the closet...

and the whole arguing with the sorting hat thing was good.
luna
2007-12-28 . chapter 7
ew... hagrid sounds kind of creepy. and it's cool how you made seamus the hot one. that almost never hapens.
Return to Top