I just found this and *squee* (I love Maedhros and Maglor, too).

Can I ask you to write your background story about Maglor trying to hide the twins because he mistakenly believes Maedhros would be against keeping them?

On the fic itself, I think you captured the characters well and very much the way they're portrayed in the Silm and the HoME writings.

I like it, shame it's a one shot. I feel there is so much more you could do with it, however it was well written and had a nice closure.

Beautiful! I love it. :)

maedhros...-sniff-...-sniffsniff-...AW!

opk ,my dazily fluff squealing is spent

Not bad. I like the explanation at the bottom of the story, but it would have added depth to have included this in the actual story itself. I'm glad more people are tackling this story, but I'd like to see more of the workings of the minds of the Kinslayers.

Nice fluff bits, good insight into the Silm history and into the implications of the twins' Peredhil status.

Good effort.