Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Did You Miss Me? - Reviews: Page 1 of 19

Oscarisamazing
2008-09-20
ch 36,
abuseGood work. I love the characterization. A few things seemed rushed, but writing something over so long, I know it's hard to pace it right.
Jestry
2008-09-15
ch 36,
abuseOH HO!
The plot thickens.

Update soon!

Sorry, this review isn't particularly helpful.

Hopefully I'm being motivational.
UPDATE UPDATE. I like this story. (:
guardgirl414
2008-09-15
ch 36,
abuseI just got back from marching band practice and when i saw you updated i was really excited! Update soon!
Hottie12345k
2008-09-15
ch 36,
abuseHow cute! I thought it was pretty cool that they didn't go to the dance and just had the little hangout party.

Good job with this chapter, it was very friendly and open, even though Christian was being a complete dunce.
projectfreq91
2008-09-15
ch 36,
abusewell the strike has some advantages i suppose...and christian is a complete toolshed. but can we have a drumline comp. chapter please? i want to see how synchronicity ends up!

great work here, more please!
Jollibee
2008-09-15
ch 36,
abuseHaha. The battles within her head always crack me up. My money is on her hooking up w/ James at prom. =D Always great stuff you come up with. Awesome.

Jollibee
JacokNortovc
2008-09-15
ch 36,
abusefebruary the shortest month
hazeleyedhottie
2008-09-13
ch 35,
abusethat was really cute! please update soon! :)
Jestry
2008-09-06
ch 35,
abuseHmm.
Well.

I like how this is about marching band. I'm kind of fetishing all things band-related since season has started.

I like how this story flows pretty well. Like, the dialogue is pretty smooth and natural, and it's not awkward to read. Also, you're pretty good at describing so that we don't feel bored, and yet understand what's going on. And like, the thing about Syd having multiple boyfriends while distantly and eventually getting together with James (we all know that's what's going to happen right? xD) is realistic. In real life, people don't just go straight from point A to point B, and I like that you've worked that in there. I really like Adrianna, her sidestory is pretty interesting, and it adds a whole new layer of depth and realism to your story, so she's not obsessing over her love life every single waking breathing moment.

That being said... your plot seems to kind of drag on. She gets mad at James, she forgives him, she gets mad, forgives him again, but their relationship isn't really much different from the way it was in the beginning. They say the same kinds of things to each other, treat each other in pretty much the same I-acknowledge-your-existence-and-we-are-semifriends kind of way. It'd be nice if their relationship developed a little.

And honestly, pulling out of the show because James got hurt? I don't know. I would expect something like a "the show must go on; let's do it for James" kind of thing. That's just my opinion, I'm not really sure what would happen in reality. But honestly, we march with random holes in our drill all the time, and it's not like it's a huge difference unless half the band is gone... plus, just out of respect for James. Do you think he really would have wanted the school to miss their chance at championships (or whatever it's called) just because he got hurt? Dunno, that just bothered me a little.

But overall, nice story. It's pretty entertaining. Update soon! (:
Jollibee
2008-09-02
ch 35,
abuseThat was awkward. Looking forward to what you're going to build with that little snippet. Loving it as usual.

-Jollibee
JacokNortovc
2008-09-02
ch 35,
abuseHUT!
projectfreq91
2008-09-02
ch 35,
abuseyay competitions! although i have never heard of fingers falling off from too much saxophone playing...although i do appreciate the best sax section award ;)

good work, more soon please!
Hottie12345k
2008-09-02
ch 35,
abuseGood job! As far as I could tell, there was only one mistake: 'pound wait bouncing' is that supposed to be weight?

This was a very well-done chapter!

Ouch, I would feel bad for Abby if she wans't such a jerk...
guardgirl414
2008-09-02
ch 35,
abuseUpdate soon!
bri835
2008-08-25
ch 10,
abuseNow we both have separate lives and lovers... And lol we're playing the music from Wicked in my band. Oh, yeah! And "Dun dun dun" Haha
Return to Top