I'm confused, didn't Joshua get his ring in that black dog fic?

That was a great story! I feel bad for Joshua. This was great though, awesome job!

So Joshua never got a ring?? Hadn't realised that - maybe my brain was in neutral! I love the idea of Joshua and Caleb becoming step-brothers - you guys so ought to do that!

Nice story - you really padded out Joshua's character and gave a good insight into what makes the guy the way he is.

As the rabid Josh fangirl I am, I seriously LOVED this story. I've been wanting for quite a while to know what happened between Ian, Fisher, Josh and Caleb and how could Caleb ever forgive them.

The whole thing was very well tied and I just adore how complex Joshua's character is and I also really love his dynamics with Caleb.

Looking forward for more fics with the two of them.

Lyra

I find it funny he likened them to the three Stooges cause I swear when they all get going it does seem to have the tendency to go that way just with a little more angst.

Loved it and the insight into Josh.. still don't think I'm going to forgive you for making me like him a little and feel sorry for him at the same time... it's just morally wrong or something.

nice story. Was hoping you were going to write about the assult on Caleb by Ian and Silas. Caleb and Joshua related, ha ha. it would make Sam and Dean's occational fights look like a tea party. Luv all the background stories keep them coming please.

I enjoyed it and look forward to whatever you choose to post next.

Great wrap-up, Tidia, I love how complex the history between Joshua and Caleb is. And of course my fav non-Winchester boy, Joshua:) Thanks for a great read, and I'm looking forward to what you're working on next!

Kelly

Tidia you did a great job creating this scene. I loved the present condition of Joshua and how it brought the memory up. I liked the Josh and Jim momment and how he didn't get the ring that time because he didn't talk, it was a great detail. Loved the story!

I liked it. I was not super anxious to read it at first because it looked to have a minimal amount of Sam and Dean, but I was pleasantly surprised to not need them to enjoy it :-) Thanks!

K

Great story! I feel sorry for Joshua now, but I don't think he is sufficiently appreciative of how forgiving Caleb has always been toward him. That Harland needs a good thrashing! I couldn't believe how cold he was, not even acting like he was concerned about how Caleb was, when he picked up Josh. If Jim had any doubts about what really happened, I'm sure that would have dispelled them. I loved the little touch at the end about Mac possibly being somewhere that Caleb didn't expect (Trying not to give anything away. I loved it--thanks so much!

Well you've done it again. Great story! I have to say that I'm really starting to like Josh, I mean Joshua:-)
and I've been waiting for this back story for a while, and have not been disappointed. These AU characters have so much depth to them that you can't help but be drawn to them. I can't wait for more from the Brotherhood.

Yay! Just like every other brotherhood story. I loved it! Can't wait to read the next one. I'll be on the look out. :) Happy Thursday!

Very entertaining, my dear. I really enjoyed it and getting the low down on what happened on that hunt.

lol i loved that you added in the phone call to Esme and that Mackland was quite obviously there lol god i love that storyline and Caleb and Joshua's reactions to it lol

This story was excellent before but i did absolutely love all the little additions that i noticed throughout it!! Great Job Ti!

Luv Tara x0x