Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Parvati Among the Slytherins - Page 1 of 4
Miranda Took 12/16/11 . chapter 1
Interesting. I like Parvati's sarcasm, and although your story is AU, you still got the part of the Patil parents wanting to keep their daughters out of Hogwarts right.

Personally, I like Amitav Ghosh, but then most sorting quizzes do put me in Ravenclaw. I'll have to wait for Pottermore to open and see if it's confirmed. I'll add here however that I also like reading the romances and the thrillers and...

Just one thing:

"Why should I keep up with my lessons if I'm going to go to the Delhi Institute? The oldest students there are probably working on spells I learned in my second year." - Unfair assumption much (even if Parvati is just bitter there)? As an Indian, I certainly don't agree.:P
SMTRodent 7/21/10 . chapter 1
Gosh, beautiful. It started out on such a fluffy note and by the end of it I had a real lump in my throat. Great ending.
6aNgElIcA9 7/10/10 . chapter 1
Really well written - I feel that is exactly how Parvati would feel if she were to decide between Hogwarts and a safer wizarding school.

:D
Lord 0f Storms 5/9/09 . chapter 1
wow, you're certainly a very skilled author i've never really read anything on Parvati before, seeing as although she's often around, she doesn't exactly feature heavily in the books, but i thoroughly enjoyed this. you captured the characters perfectly (especially Parvati) and i could easily believe everything that happened. a favourite if ever i've seen one
Katseng 4/4/09 . chapter 1
This is absolutely lovely on so many levels. The character development and the relationship between Parvati and Padma is wonderfully depicted.

Thank you so much for sharing!

Kat
azab 1/10/09 . chapter 1
loved it
Molu4All 12/2/08 . chapter 1
This was SO well written! I loved your interpretations! The best Patil fan fiction I've read yet
livesonwisteria 5/22/08 . chapter 1
Great. I like how you developed her character, the end was great as well
1a2b3c4d5e 12/11/07 . chapter 1
i really liked this. I think it's brilliant how you've portrayed parvati, and i like how it started out and everything.

i'm really glad i read it, thanks :)
Terri Stephens 8/17/07 . chapter 1
Wonderful story. So Parvati thinks that Ron is "amazingly immature"? Ron is developmentally average, for a boy. Hermione, on the other hand, is developmentally immature: she has no social skills at all, but people tend to confuse precocity for maturity. She's just beginning to catch up with the other kids by the end of Book 7!

Harry seems unusually mature because of growing up surrounded by sick, dangerous people: that is, he's learned to pay attention and meet expectations as survival skills.

JKR has created a lot of characters that are no better than cardboard; Parvati and Lavender are fully defined by their boy-crazy, hair-clothes-makeup and Divination obsessions, just as Pansy and Draco are fully defined as spoiled, bigoted bullies. In book six it looked like JKR was going to turn Draco into an actual person, but I guess she changed her mind. My guess is we know nothing about Padma because she's not really a person; she's fully defined as Parvati's identical twin.

In this story you have made Parvati and Padma into real people. I find myself wanting to point out to Parvati that she has the same ability to be selfish and nasty that Pansy has, but Pansy's parents encourage her bad behavior and the Patils do exactly the opposite. Also, all survivors hate therapy, but it really helps. Unfortunately all therapists are not good at what they do: you have the right to ask for a better doctor.
adeckofcards 4/13/07 . chapter 1
very nice. I have a soft spot for parvati and it's great that you took a not so known character and developed her so well. keep wrting.
Phoenix.G.Fawkes 11/14/06 . chapter 1
Just loved it. You've taken an under-used character and developed her wonderfully, giving her a depth rarely seen in fan fiction. Congratulations!
Ohyeah100 7/7/06 . chapter 1
That was great. I love this. i liked young Draco and Young pansy. it was all so great. Nice, Addsed to my list.

Ohyeah100
OMG FAN 5/31/06 . chapter 1
I LUV IT!

/10!
Sera dy Relandrant 5/18/06 . chapter 1
Since when was Parvati a blue-blooded witch? And so Slytherin-connected? Are you Indian - I am.

It's very good actually - simply splendid.
59 found: Page 1 2 3 .. 4 Next »
Return to Top