Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Whisper - Page 1 of 6
Passionflowering
2009-09-14 . chapter 7
... I am speechless.
I can't really find the words to explain how I felt reading this story. It was so beautiful and perfect, and captured the very essence of a tragic love. Gah. I don't know. I really can't put it into words.
Absolutely stunning story :).
Elennar
2009-08-24 . chapter 7
This is very well written. Good imagery and nice cultural details. The plot and feel to the story definitely has an east-asian flavour to it, especially on the use of musical instruments, symbolism and poetry. The tragic ending is fitting and dare I say it, typical of asian romances. The story is good enough to stand as original fiction and should.

Now, some comments, which I hope will not offend you. My first impression is deja-vu. Akizuki's story is rather close to a drama on Korean Geisha Hwang Jini. Not saying you copied it or anything bad. Just the impression.

Secondly, Tezuka's death is rather sudden and forced. Which I feel, is a weak point in the plot. Someone of his caliber and intelligence, on high alert for treachery, won't be caught off-guard so easily.

Akizuki's death is beautifully written. A good mix of drama, action and emotions. Tragic without cloying exaggerated melodrama.
Chibi-chan990
2008-11-27 . chapter 6
wow, I can't help but reread this story again and again. Your writing still really captures my attention. I love how their love is the same time subtle but passionate nonetheless, and the way you describe their interactions and their thoughts when they are away from each other is like pieces of a puzzle fitting wonderfully together, and the way you led the story up until the point of climax is simply amazing. ^__^ I hope I can write like this someday, thank you so much for the wonderful fanfic!
bangthewallthenclapandcry
2008-10-31 . chapter 7
aw... I loved this fic. But do you think you can create an alternate ending where Fuji and Tezuka lives happily after ever as well?
valynn
2008-09-08 . chapter 7
Ah...that truly was astounding and beautiful. Really touches the soul. It's written so elegantly and the poetry is such a flowing language! It's as if the whole story were a song...graceful words. Really love your writing. The ending is rather sad...but that's the beauty of it. Keep it up! Good work...
APB on review
2008-08-30 . chapter 7
Ok, whoever calls this angst should read Romeo and Juliet. Of course this is a better story, no offence to Shakespeare.

They are together; they just don't happen to be alive for that to happen.
Yukairi
2008-07-28 . chapter 7
even if they did have to die,I was hoping that they would at least meet one last time like in rurouni kenshin where kaoru and kenshin met 1 last time time before kenshin died.Luved your story,it was so descriptive but so much angst T_T
Chibi-chan990
2008-05-23 . chapter 7
;_; WHY?! SO MUCH TEZUFUJI ANGST!! *sniff* that last chapter broke my heart...but I do so dearly loved the writing...perhaps you can include an epilogue where they meet again as classmates in Seigaku?
StarDancer1234
2008-05-06 . chapter 7
So sad. :(

This story is so beautiful, and so well written. All the details seem so authentic (no matter how many times you say they might not be), and even though this is AU, they are so, so in character.

Amazing job; but I would have absolutely LOVED to read more about Akizuki and the Kyoto Tiger.

I adored when you wrote, 'his beautiful, proud Akizuki'...how touching. :(

An absolute joy (and sorrow?) to read. :)

StarDancer
shourin
2008-04-16 . chapter 7
OMG! i just read your fic last week up to chapter 4 and it was amazing!

and what's more amazing is - i open a week later and it's finished! you're da bomb my dear!

anyway, haven't read the last 3 chapter. i'll drop another review after i read everything.

Shourin
Kid9535
2008-03-01 . chapter 7
Most beautiful story I've heard in a while. When I read yuor story I thought, this is like Winter Cicada and Memoirs of a Geisha put together. I recently broke free from my Death Note rut but after reading yours, I was suddenly reminded of all the good authors like you who write Death Note fictions. They were very well-versed in the area they write in and they did a lot of research on it too. Well-done! :D
mesmerizedbyceruleaneyes
2008-03-01 . chapter 1
i love this. wonderful descriptions.
MSYOU
2008-02-16 . chapter 7
M beautiful story ^^ the ending was truly appropriate even though I wish they could have been together a little longer alive oh and the poetry sure was something can you tell me were you got the passages from? anyways thanks for posting I’m adding this to my favorites XD
Pax Silva
2008-02-15 . chapter 7
This was a wonderful story, the writing and the era that it takes place along with the genre is magnificent, and the writing is on par with everything, I really enjoyed readying it. I've added it to my C2 community, it's well worth sharing it with ther people!
AniFre101
2008-02-06 . chapter 7
That was great! I love the pairing! Can you e-mail me the meanings of the words from Chapter 1 to Chapter 7 please? I'd appreciate it. Arigatou.
Return to Top