Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Fullmetal Alchemist and The Sin Alchemist
alchemichelper101
2008-07-17 . chapter 6
WHA?! Why not continue it?! I'm starting to like it...it's pretty good really...please continue it
I-Am-Special-Hear-Me-Roar
2007-12-01 . chapter 2
I'm sorry, but I still don't see how 'imitation life' makes this a reasonable plot. To make something seem alive, she'd need a soul for it. Cornello made that large bird using the souls of smaller birds, but it is nothing comparable to what you're proposing. This plot is skating on exceedingly thin ice, as the skill specified is not one that is possible given the setting you have chosen.
The only way her 'imitation life' is possible is if it's a hoax or she has one of the sins fake philosophers stones that allows for a dead animal to be temporarily animated, and there is no way she could have created a living, breathing chick out of fire made from sand. This is less like alchemy and more like magic.

Sophie
Miss Mercury Blue
2007-08-22 . chapter 4
Aw, I love your story. Ria is so original. I really hope you continue this story!
darkfarie-angel
2007-08-19 . chapter 3
Please continue it is very good.
Sasharu
2007-08-19 . chapter 3
He-heh? WHAT? No, continue! You'll get more reviews later on, definitely! ^^ Can't wait to see what happens next - things will reach a climax... ^^ ^^ ^^ ^^ ^^
Ohka Breynekai
2007-08-19 . chapter 3
Very nicely done! This story is extremely well-written, and I you've created a very unique OC.

Hehe, I feel sorry for Al too, lol.

So, with that said, please update soon! Looking forward for more!
O.B.
Sasharu
2007-08-17 . chapter 1
Your prologue is really good too! (Sorry I skipped chapter 1 before, I was in a rush) I feel like most of the people are rather in-character, and I can't wait to see what happens. I'm pretty sure that this new power uses some other more 'sinful' deadly power... olalala *shiny lights* ^^
DemonRaily
2007-08-17 . chapter 2
U did good job, keap it going:)
Sasharu
2007-08-16 . chapter 2
...I really love your writing style! It's very descriptive and not-so-boring at the same time. But just get one thing straight: Equivelent Exchange, the principle mentioned at the begnning of EVERY EPISODE. You can't just create life from nothing... I'd love to see where you go with this, though! *favs* *alerts*
Return to Top