|
|
| Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search | Login Register Extras |
| CeliaLauna 2008-06-23 ch 1, | abuseHi! Nice one-shot! I love how innocent, and, well, BLOND they are. hm... (Yeah, I'm kinda obessed with Chyan, I love them!) When I saw the title, there was a song that poped in my head. I actually liked this more. (IDK if you know it: By your side, from Tokio Hotel. The original is An Deiner Seite. at least, I think you spell it like that) Your song really fits. Nice job! X~X~X Celia |
| Sandshrew777 2008-02-17 ch 1, | abuseYou miss with Kelsi early. Something about her voice doesn't jive. It's disjointed and not quite right until she makes the comment about needing her girls. Then I think you find her again for the rest of the story. The girls' scheming is cute and well-placed Of course Taylor can convince Chad better than Gabriella can Ryan. It doesn't help that Ryan's a bit smarter than Chad and Gabriella's not an easy liar. Cute characterization all around. I wanted you to make the boys get into the song a bit more. I wanted more attention paid to their body language, but of course Kelsi's busy. I'm not sure how to resolve that, but that's just what I was hoping to see. As for the song, I think it's certainly pretty and packed with meaning. You've got it written here in a singing format instead of a lyrics format. What I mean is that I can straight sing this song with all of the improvised runs you have written into it already...and I'd rather them be improvised. Every Oh, No, and stretched note ("fee-e-el") can take a hike. Your singers will get it right for ya, trust me. ;) You end smartly and well. Good for you and trusting your instincts. A make-out scene would have underscored your song. Great creativity, and cute ideas. Strong work! Keep writing. |
| Billie the fourth sage 2007-12-31 ch 1, | abuseXD Kelsi the schemer O_o XD Just so you know, Chryan or Chad/Ryan or whatever you call it is my fave pairing XD Nice song ^^ |
| sweet blood 2007-09-09 ch 1, anon. | abuselove the story i just finish seeing the movie today and i felt like reading a fan fic about chad and ryan this is good ^^ |
| black lady knight 2007-09-07 ch 1, | abuseloved it! |
| akari-hayashi 2007-09-07 ch 1, | abuseAw, that is so sweet! Nice effort on the song! The most amusing part must be about Ry suntanning. I was just thinking today about whether he even plays at the beach. He is so incredibly white. |
| :-D 2007-09-07 ch 1, anon. | abuselove it! |
| Promise-V 2007-09-06 ch 1, | abuseoh my...i love Chyan now because of HSM 2 great story laterz, Promise-V |
| lilsteves 2007-09-06 ch 1, anon. | abuseThat was a pretty good song! Great job! The ending was really sweet |
| rinoakes 2007-09-06 ch 1, | abuseaw its so sweet!! |
| empath89 2007-09-06 ch 1, | abuseaww...that was so cute! i loved it. and kelsi was great...so in character. i'd love to see more...especially that multi-chapter chryan fic! hugs...empath |
| StillThereForMe 2007-09-06 ch 1, | abuseAdorable! Kelsi playing matchmaker, and then slowly fading into the background as the song goes on...so in character for her! Loved it. Great job! |