Even if you have read Azkaban already, this story is interesting. It's always interesting to see something like this. It's refreshing.

Wow...I like it!

That was well written. It probably deserves a ten, but I've used so MANY og those... No. Heh-heh. It really was pretty good, but there were one or two spelling errors, and, well... I dunno.

Gypsy, my friend, amazing! i dun carr aboute speelin eerors. Hehe, just kidding. Well, all fanfics have spelling errors, so people, pass them up, and give Gypsy a hand . . . or two! ;)

Very nice. And such great detail. Cool fic!

Love it love it love it! Professor Erwin is a fresh, new, AND great edition to the Harry Potter family!

Wow! That's a good idea. At first I was pretty confused. But now I can't wait to read the next one. I want to know what's wrong with Erwin, I can't figure it out.

I didn't know Ms. Rowling wrote fan fiction.

This story's great It's very well written and very dramatic.

Okay, but it needs to get to the point...

who wrote this cursed piece of literature? what utter nonsense! i demand a rewrite!

in hope you may have better writing days,

Hermione Granger,class prefect

:x

well...it isnt that good but its ok... :/

has a drawn, haunted look on face Wow...

ooooooohh, spooky!