Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Marigolds - Page 1 of 3
Siriusmunchkin
2009-10-14 . chapter 1
Beautiful and romantic. And very Luna
err...anonymous?
2009-09-07 . chapter 1
That's really sweet. I'm a fan of the Luna/Neville pairing, and this is a great fic. Quick thing, though.

"There was a collection of ash trees down on the edge of the forest, and so she’d gone there as soon as she could, and found the tree that most resembled what she thought she wanted, someone strong and true and kind, and although she’d found strong and true, kind was harder to tell in trees, and so she’d picked the one that seemed to have the most birds nesting in it, and settled for that."
I don't mean to be harsh, but this sentence stuck out to me as rather awkward. It's awfully long, and it feels like a bunch of clauses strung together by commas and "ands." I think that with just a little rewording and breaking up into smaller sentences, you could make it something a bit less clunky and a bit more flowy.

Otherwise, great fic! Oh, and I'd like a poppy from Sirius.
hergoldeneyes
2009-07-18 . chapter 1
April would be liking a Rose from Ronald Weasley for reviewing this amazingly amazing fanfiction, please and thank youhs ^^

Do I get a cookie if I favorite? ;D
bookwormofmassiveproportions
2009-07-14 . chapter 1
EEk! It makes me all warm and fuzzy inside. Yay!
Aicalas
2008-12-11 . chapter 1
it's just lovely, a stunning characterization of both neville and luna. (I hold out that N/L is canon, lol) I love how you've humanized Luna, and really made her realiztic--I've always felt that JK never really let her character have the gravity I think she could posess.
xCharlie-Groupiex
2008-07-01 . chapter 1
That was such a beautiful story, I'm glad that Luna and Neville ended up together instead of with Hannah and Rolf. This was such a magical oneshot, their love is so strong it makes me feel sorry that they never got together in the books.

But atleast I'll have cute fics like this to console me! Great job!

xox Sacha
pop-pop-bananas
2008-01-20 . chapter 1
I love this. I think that Neville deserves to be happy, and Luna is just the person he needs. Luna is just the right person for everyone. She's perfect.
Keep it up!
X
Argentus
2008-01-07 . chapter 1
So, so beautiful. I’m in love with the fairy-tale like ring to your words; your strong but gentle Neville, and your whimsical Luna. I love how the kiss is so…tranquil and quiet but strong enough to link them to each other for years. And I think a parrot is *perfect* for Luna by the way :p
Your writing style is absolutely lovely!
Oh, and I get flowers from Sirius! :)
RubeusHagrid34
2007-12-24 . chapter 1
That was really cute! I liked it a lot :)
I'm Just Drawn That Way
2007-12-03 . chapter 1
Very sweet. First Neville/Luna story I've read, and I liked it. They really do seem well suited - they're both such gentle souls - and I like the way you write them.
Not sure what HP character I want my flower from: I love Harry, Neville, and Remus the most. (I suppose Remus is more appropriate for me, age-wise, and his character does seem to have more depth, so maybe he's my guy. But I'll let him choose the flower!)
JaneRain
2007-11-28 . chapter 1
Aww, that was lovely. Too bad J.K. has since dashed any theories of their canon future. I think Neville/Luna is so sweet.
LEGOLASroxmysox
2007-10-08 . chapter 1
aw this is so sad and sweet! Really touching. You should write more Neville/Luna stories. This one is going straight to my favs list!
fishy959
2007-10-06 . chapter 1
omg that was sniff' so beautiful sniff'
Simply Just
2007-10-03 . chapter 1
That was too sweet for words! I loved it!

By the way, I get a red rose from Neville. :) Even though he will always be Luna's.
Da Phoenix 13
2007-10-03 . chapter 1
Aw, that was adorable! I'm not normally a Neville/Luna fan, but I think you may have started to convert me... ;) great job!
Return to Top