Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Broken Idols
ROBINV
2008-03-30 . chapter 1
Poor John! Such a miserable job to do alone. I feel for him, snd for the boys. He means well, wants to help others--but at what cost to his sons and himself? Excellent, as always! Love, Robin
alwaysateen
2007-10-15 . chapter 3
I like it. It's a tough way to learn that your dad is not always the hero or that you brother can't always be there to protect you. On the other hand, even as sick as he was, Dean never let Sam down. But John really burst Sam's bubble.
Great story.
KAZ2Y567i
2007-10-14 . chapter 3
Bravo Maya! Another lovely story.
Sam has finally come into his own I think with this story. He is beginning to realise that his idol is no longer John. And that he can do well without him for he has supplanted him with another...Dean.
John not listening to Sam when he first arrived,thinking that Dean had shirked his this be the beginning of the rift between them? Nice idea here.
I loved the tenderness and how Sam really wanted to look after his brother. My favourite lines..."Sam grabbed his brother with both hands and buried his face in his sweat soaked shirt and sobbed. When a shaking hand stumbled over his back onto his head, it only made Sam cry all that much harder"...simply lovely...squees!
Keep up the good work Maya. I'll be looking for more of your fics.
DeeUnnatural
2007-10-14 . chapter 3
I like the way you explain the rif in the relationship with Sam and John. It being a simple thing as an illness, still makes the Winchesters ordinary. Look foward to reading more of your stories.
may7fic
2007-10-14 . chapter 3
Really nice take on what may well have been the beginning of the end. Excellent voices here and I felt deep sympathy for all 3 characters.
sammygirl1963
2007-10-14 . chapter 3
Awesome story! If John had just taken the time to listen to Sammy, things would have been back to normal. In stead, this moment started them onto the road of gifhting with each other that would ultimately lead to Sam walking away!
Return to Top