Lovely! I love the 300 hundred year twist you put on it.

I'm speechless! You did a wonderful job. I think it was a great idea to have her on the Flying Dutchman with him. I think it's so true to their characters and I think you did a beautiful job in capturing that. I haven't found to many POTC fanfic that makes me feel as though I am in the world of Pirates and you have definitely achieved that with this story. Brava!

Beautiful story! Utterly beautiful, wonderful work!!

Beautifully written, I dare say. Not many FFs are this amazing! Bravo/Brava!

your story was breathtaking and left me with a need for more. In my opinion In a score from 1-10 I would rate this a 10. you should seriusly think about becoming an author.

Wow! That was one of the best fics I've ever read. It's heartbreakingly sad and then...the light at the end of the tunnel. The ending is just beautiful. Great job! Definitely between my favourites.

wow...i'm speechless. this is officially the greatest W/E story i have ever read. wow...

Very diffrent.

k made me cry...alittle lost...he made her immortal?

I am so on the verge of crying right now! I have my ipod on the saddest song right now and I love it! Omg that was so beautiful? But how did she live? Did he save her? how? Oh I want to know. I really wish they didn't stop after At Worlds End, I mean what will happen, I mean will Will keep coming back to port royal after all the years and watch as she grows older and older? Is that a fate that anyone would want?

That was wonderful. Great story.

Definitely one of the best fanfictions I've ever read. The story is good, the details are good, and it moves at a good pace. The only slight complaint I have with it is that some of the paragraphs are long, so they are hard to read. But this is over all a wonderful story. Great Job.

That was beautiful and just what I needed. Thanks for posting.

Very, very well done. You had me convinced Elizabeth was actually dead--she had a hero's end, facing the wave not as a fine lady or a pirate or a pining girl, but strong and proud and defiant as herself. When Will took her into the crew, it didn't feel cheap, it felt right.
Bravo.

that was really interesting. not what i expected, but it was really good. Nice story.