 Cassandra30 2009-05-25 . chapter 1Sweet. |
 Ducky'sgirl4ever 2009-04-08 . chapter 1A great story. Very good. |
 godwit 2009-01-19 . chapter 1This was beautiful. I really like the idea that Snape finally gets some rest and time to heal. |
 skeptyx 2008-06-14 . chapter 1It's a beautiful, peaceful story. Thank you, Professor.
~Ptyx |
 Kasia 2008-01-23 . chapter 1 Dear Logospilgrim,
I like Your stories.
Severus deserved for - peace. Redemption. His sacrifice was complete... I, I don't know, how.. how to say. And what. About Potions Master.
I hope You'll end "O my soul".
I hope - maybe - You'll write to me, someday?
*hug* |
 tall oaks 2008-01-05 . chapter 1Thank you for pointing your story out; I quite enjoyed the tenderness you showed for Snape. Your really did a good thing in having Harry want and hope to speak to his former professor.
Dumbledore became problematic for me back in Goblet of Fire; I wondered what he really was doing--how much he cared for those whose lives he held in his hand. |
 XiaoGui 2007-11-10 . chapter 1Yes, it would have been great if a scene like this would have been included in the book. It would have made it far more conciliatory for us Snape fans. It's a pity.
Nice little story, thank you! |
 Alex the Anachronistic 2007-11-04 . chapter 1Tres bien! |
 adaon45 2007-10-29 . chapter 1I absolutely love this story; but then again, I have long loved your website and want to thank you for it, as well as for this.
Yes, I wish JKR had included a scene like this with Harry and Snape in the King's Cross chapter. I guess she wanted to keep the action going at this crucial point--and she is rather odd about Snape when she speaks about him publically, a mystery I shall not attempt to fathom--but it is so important to me that we see Harry coming to the point where he can forgive and value Snape. I particularly love Dumbledore's line about healing needing time, even in the next world.
I also like your showing us Snape's desperation at the beginning, when he thinks he's failed by not being able to tell Harry what he still has to do. And his relief when Harry actually shows up is palpable.
You know, it is rather remarkable that Snape is finally able to let Harry see so much of his past, including those early scenes where he is such a young outcast. This seems to indicate something very important about Snape's shifting feelings about Harry. Nice movement in your story, by the way, from Snape's thinking of Harry as "Potter" to finally calling him by his first name.
I do hope you'll write more! And I eagerly await your book on Snape. |
 Strega Triss 2007-10-25 . chapter 1Please write a sequel! I speak for many when I say that it would be much appreciated:) |
 kimcatus 2007-10-25 . chapter 1Oh that was beautiful...exactly how I wanted it to end. Once again you have amazed me with your writing. Thank you for writing that. |
 winters_lily 2007-10-24 . chapter 1 A beautiful story, Professor. I was so glad to see that you had witten fic again, as I've always enjoyed your writing a great deal. I do like your characterization of Dumbledore here; I only wish we had seen as much concern and tenderness towards Severus in the books themselves...and your Harry is spot-on. A lovely and peaceful bit of writing. (oh, and..same winters_lily as on livejournal) |
 FireChildSlytherin5 2007-10-24 . chapter 1Nice. :) Hey, do u know any DH spoiler fics that has Severus as a spirit in Hogwarts instead resting in peace in the after life?
If so, I would be happy to know the title and author!
Thanks. |
 Iva1201 2007-10-24 . chapter 1I don't particularly like he still dies but then, it's still so much better than the actual book - except Dumbledore in canon probably never really cared. |
 MysticSong1978 2007-10-24 . chapter 1Dearest Professor,
This is quite lovely. I am always pleased to read your work.
(same MysticSong as on livejournal) |