 Hikaru1223 2009-10-05 . chapter 1A sad story but I must say:
Dang that was good!
Depressing, yes. Poetic, Very.
Hope you can make another one with a positive ending. It's too sad seeing our lovely Goddess be depressed like that. |
 stigotte 2009-09-30 . chapter 1well that was...depressing :/ |
 Robert Varulfur 2009-07-07 . chapter 1There is a simple saddness to this short story. Its a good plot line, and I think it would have made a good longer story. |
 Anon 2009-04-27 . chapter 1 This is a sad piece, but I love the way you write. |
 mi-cchii 2009-01-17 . chapter 1aw.. I love it. It's so sweet yet sad. |
 Anon 2008-07-27 . chapter 1 Beautifully saddening. It was great. |
 Lost in the Shadow 2008-01-09 . chapter 1Very good. |
 Audley 2007-12-28 . chapter 1Oh...very nice. Very poetic. Simple, sweet, and yet serious. Lovely! |
 Eric 2007-11-28 . chapter 1 I thought this was pretty good. Even though I have never been one to dance, and in fact I do not know how to dance, I have always love scenes in Anime where people dance. Anyways, I though this was a good insight into Haruhi's character, and I really liked the ending, I could really see her in here room dancing with no one(does she live alone or what?) If I had to critique I guess I would say that sometimes it was a little confusing if Haruhi was the narrator or if someone else was. Overall very good. |
 the grey mage 2007-11-23 . chapter 1this, was way too deep. i really loved this. thank you. |
 Kuma-cchi 2007-11-15 . chapter 1Aw it was sweet. though a little OTT. but nice, I liked reading from Haruhi's POV for a change. :)
Keep it up! |
 Silver Sailor Ganymede 2007-11-07 . chapter 1Very sweet, I liked it. |
 Theos Amneos 2007-11-06 . chapter 1I like this generally. Here is some criticism, though.
I don't think Haruhi would feel the need to practice dancing. A precocious prodigy, that one. I also don't think the way you've defined "extraordinary" quite fits, although there's no conflict with Haruhi's motivation because after all she said quite clearly that the reason she's into the extraordinary is because it's more fun. I agree with the general premise that Haruhi would find dancing fun, but might hesitate at forcing Kyon into it due to the implications.
Also, the last line. Seems out of place somehow. "keep her warm at night" seems a bit base, a bit too simple. If that were all Kyon and partners in general were supposed to do, I don't think it'd be too difficult for her to prove that she isn't really "all alone in this world". |
 Pandassassin 2007-11-06 . chapter 1good fic, 5/5. btw i would dance with haruhi lol L8R |
 anonymous jane 2007-11-06 . chapter 1 i liked that, a little bit of kyonxharuhi (the best couple in that anime) nice ideas. |