Minisinoo,

This is an awesome piece of work. I like the tatoo and the reason behind Marie getting it. Keep it up.

Auua

That was amazing. You made me cry. You're right; most of the stories deal with Rogue dealing with Logan's memories rather than Magneto's. I think it's because it's easier to tie it into a romance that way. I like these stories much better. Thank you for writing it.

Interesting, more so with Marie getting a tat.

Aw...this makes me want to read Night.

I'm actually quite surprised that you would write about the Holocaust and have a connection to Magneto and, in turn, Rogue, Scott, and Xavier. Very nice job once again. To be quite frank, I expected another OOC author that had a thousand reviews for a story that has nothing to do with what the real author wrote about. Ya know, another person that adds teen drama and reaps in reviews like it's food.

Thank God you are much more mature (and a better writer) than that. All your stories convey messages and have some historical background into it. lives because of authors like you.

It is exquisite.

Wow. Amazing. Perfect characterization, truly thought provoking content.

Fantastic.

I have read your Harry potter fanfiction on your website and this is just as good as the rest of your work. The question of how Rouge would deal with Eric's memories has always intrested me and I think you answered that question with a great deal of finesse. I liked your use of Night, it is a book everyone should have to read at some point in their lives. You are a great writer, I promise there will always be a ready audience for all that you write.

I have just got to tell you wow! This is realy good if not slightly depressing. But it is realy realy good.

I stumbled across this from a recommendation it received in a C2 community. I'd never read it before, although I was familiar with you by reputation and some of your meta posts at LJ. To say I had high expectations of your writing is an understatement. And I must say you fulfilled every one.

This is a very solid piece, well-researched, with dynamic characterizations and a poignant message. I respect your ability to work in moral ambiguity and optimism into your writing without banging the reader over the head with it. I also enjoyed Rogue's slow adjustment to Erik's memories and the lessons she encountered in the books and scribbles from the Professor and Erik. Also noted how you worked Scott Summers into the story, a character you are excellent at writing.

I know you aren't writing in the X-Men fandom anymore. And that is a pity, since it is a lesser community without you.

Wow. This story was incredible. It brought out so many emotions in me, really moved me. You had the perfect combo of the memoirs and your own writing. It was well written and poignant. I especially loved the ending. Rogue doing something like that for Moshe and Eric so that it would never be forgotten was, wow. So yeah, wonderful story, excellent writing, please write more stories as equally touching!

I don't think I've ever read anything more touching and heartbreaking and yet poingantly wonderful in all my life. I've encourage many people I know to read this story, because I beleive it fundamentally important that people do. To remember, to know, to understand. You have done a job so much better than amazing, then touching, than astounding, that I know no singular word to describe it.

AkaOkamiRyu

We need more like these.

This is very moving. I have been wanting to write a story about Erik and Rogue gaining his memories along with Logan's for a long time now. You got to it before me, oh well. I have always liked Erik and been fascinated by his story and experiences, I'm glad other people look deeper into his motivations as well. Well done, and all the effort you put into the research was appreciated, it gave this story more depth and heart.

)

-Kat

Yes, very nice. It did both. GRAIL put me off, or I'd have gone through this stuff ages ago. I think I told you you impressed me ;.; I go through one of the most traumatizing museum exhibitions I've ever faced and then I get this story on the same day. Which dragon to fight, you know? And I had no idea anyone could get that thin and still move...