Real good story. I thought people were pretty in character for the brotherhood universe.

Cute! great fic!

aww!! i love it as always! and I love how you name all the dogs after To Kill A Mockingbird people! hey, if there's another dog, will you name him Jem?

Sweet ending which rounds the story off nicely.

Doctor Singer! - Could Mac be anymore incredulous! LOL.

I so enjoyed this. Much as I love angst, this was the kind of fic I needed to read today. It was both funny and heartwarming.

It took me awhile to warm up to this AU - but it has finally happened. This is such a wonderful universe. I love the family that has been created.

I look forward to the other fics mentioned. Nice job. Seemed very appropriate for Bela to have obtained the painting for Caleb.

--shan

great job with the epilogue! it was really nice...and i relished in the dean/caleb hug at the end. it was a nice picture in my mind...hehe. again, great job...i really enjoyed reading this one. hope you had a merry christmas!

Aww, that was a really nice ending. And that's about as much Bela as I can handle - nice to see that Dean finally got one over on her, even if it didn't happen in the 'actual' show!

I'd like to know what else is on that roll of film...!

One of the things I like most about the Brotherhood AU is the sense of family that the hunters have - which kind of reflects one of the most important themes of the actual show. I think you did a great job of putting that across towards the end of the chapter!

Great epi. The presents were perfect!

LOL - the ending of this chapter reminded me a little bit of the Wizard of Oz (when the guys are doing the name thing).

It reminded me of the scene where Dorothy finally wakes up and explains where she has been and she points at the others and says, "And you were there, and you, and so were you!"

:D

That's kind of what happened to Mac and it was struck my funny bone. Excellent.

I absolutely loved this. Dean getting Caleb his Mom's picture was great. I can't wait for the other stories. Great job!

That was really sweet!! I love the ending with Caleb & Dean sharing that moment with the gift giving! Very AW worthy! Great job!!

That was an amazing story! I was so close to break into tears is not even funny. Dean as a doctor was priceless and Mac and Bobby hilarious! The ending was sweet but heart breaking. Great story, totally loved it.

Love it. The interqction between Dean and Caleb is so tangible, especially over Dean's possible fate. The fact that Dean is afraid he will be used against his friends. Funny as well with Esme & Mac situation. Happy hols!