I was kinda hoping for more, not like a yelling fit from Harry, but more emotional reaction to all of the crap that has come to him because Dumbles thought he had the right to make these decisions.

He's met the parents he should've had, seen the life he could've lived if not for two old men playing chess with his life, but he seems the same sadsack from canon whosse gonna let Dumbles trick him in to martyring himself.

hm... i will admit i liked the 4th year better... but the 5th year is good. i am sorry we did not get to hear more about harry's time in the alternate universe... it all seemed rather rushed to me. and it is a little weird? where are you going to go with the read of this book? i can't firgure it out. but you must have a plan so i won't question you!!

oh and don't get me wrong i LOVE this story and can't wait for an update!

~where the wind blows

Brilliant chappie, keep up the good work, i love the story and don't particularly mind how long it takes you to update, I just want to read the rest of the story and don't mind how long it takes.

- Padfoot-Moony-an-Prongs -

I love this story so I hope that you update soon I really want to know how this ends.

wow, ive been reading this and the hp4 one in practically every spare moment I've had the past few days and I love it!! Cant believe I've got to the end of whats been posted :( I really really like the story, I like how u have the depressing angsty chapters cz I really like angst but u have also put in more lighthearted chapters like the prank wars cz altho i really like the depressing chapters, I do find they make me feel kinda depressed so the fun chapters help to break that up and cheer me up a bit!! Hope u update soon!!

Aw Remus.. D:
Of course death eaters had to come! It's a good thing they didn't drink too much firewhisky!

awesome! like always.

I liked Riddle giving him an occlumency lesson, hopefully he learned something. I felt bad about Remus*, especially as he died just kinda suddenly. I can't wait to see how Harry deals with Dumbles and Snape knowing now what he knows.

One of the things that makes the "cool uncle sev" pill easier to swallow, has been how otherwise you've kept to his canon persona, he's still not very pleasant and as Harry discovers here, a crap teacher.

I also like, yet hated for Harry's sake at the same time, how you have him inevitably falling for Lily and James despite knowing in his head and heart he'll be leaving eventually. I hope you have something planned for him back in his world to make up for it, a girlfriend perhaps(Luna?)? Unending angst is a chore to read.

Nice as well, is how he is making good use of his time here getting ready, and getting angry at Dumbles for all the mistakes he's made.

Cant wait for more!

As long as you don't abandon the story, I'll wait patiently (well not patiently, but what can I do?) I know how rough school is sometimes.

Anyways, the little dinner thing was cute, I hope Harry has some more bonding moments with Lily and James, even if it makes things harder in the end.

I love the parallel universe thing, it makes this story different from all the rest of the stories that are out there about sirius and remus adopting harry!

The canon pairings also make the storyline less confusing cos we already know wo is with who!

Try and update soon, its really good!!

More! I want more! I just love this story! I'm always so sad when I get to the end of the chapter. Can't wait for your update!

OH OH OH! UPDATE SOON UPDATE SOON!

I'll admit, at first I thought the AU thing was a little awkward, but I LOVE IT! ;o) You're such a great writer!
Keep up the great work and update soon!!
xoxo