Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Wouldn't Be the Same - Reviews: Page 1 of 2

q.thews
2008-07-15
ch 1,
abuseVery nice.
It solve that big practical problem (thinking about Hermione without NEWT...)
It is quite realistic too.
And the last lines, very fitting.
Ciao!
banner
2008-05-22
ch 1,
abuseThat was fun and funny and interesting. Thank you for making me smile.
Muria
2008-03-23
ch 1,
abuseLove it! This is a great interpretation of what could happen after the war... 'Eighth years' with their unique status and leadership roles are a nice background detail. The healing wounds of lost loved ones... Protective McGonigal... Lovely.

But, Snape's just perfect. I'd love to see this scene on-screen, but the movies, unfortunantly, don't even follow the books acurately... Sorry, I'm not a fan of the movies purely because of the altered events...

Anyway, you have a nice list of stories. I've been reading your Naruto series of how to make characters angry. Those are pretty funny. :)
Trinity Day
2008-03-12
ch 1,
abuseI must admit, I wasn't expecting him to show up at the new DADA teacher. Nicely done!
belladonnacordial
2008-03-01
ch 1,
abuseOh, if only! Thanks for this. It really made my day. I agree that Harry and Hermione at least would go this route. You made a good case for Ron to join them. Loved the description of a spectral Snape. Replacing Snape's idea of 'celebrity' with 'war hero' made me laugh. Good to see that the trio are in such good hands.
nerdybookworm
2008-02-27
ch 1,
abuseHahaha :) I'm glad Harry's laughing again.
Tillantria
2008-02-26
ch 1,
abuseI liked that ending and upon reflection, after reading your glimpse, I really enjoyed the title.
kateydidnt
2008-02-26
ch 1,
abuseFantastic story! I love it.
DeengoBlue
2008-02-02
ch 1,
abuseOh fantastic! THIS should have been the epilogue to DH. You gave us the glimpse of how things were like after the battle--of how things chnaged, of how they remained the same--without bogging down into and then, and then, and then.
And Snape. For that alone, is luv.
Melody DeMort
2008-01-31
ch 1,
abuseOh! I love you. So much inspiration in one dramatic and anticlimatic plot-bunny! I do love snape- he's my favorite character actually- [a fair bit because he's played by Alan Rickman in the movies] and this is the first ghost post-dh I've seen of him. Will you continue?
westingturtle
2008-01-23
ch 1, anon.
abuseNice. I can just see this happening after the war, and while I am not sure if Snape would find teaching enough of a reason to stay after the war, it sure finds someone who is competent and hates Harry. And, after all that has happened, Harry's reaction is just perfect.
rose griffes
2008-01-22
ch 1,
abuseThis was such an enjoyable read!
Perri Smith
2008-01-22
ch 1,
abuseOh. My. God. That's... that's just evil. And beautiful. And brilliant! < dies laughing >
kcinlondon
2008-01-21
ch 1,
abuseFantastic! I always felt we were cheated on not seeing more of DADA Snape.

/though part of me did wonder of Lucius would come swishing through the door
ang
2008-01-21
ch 1, anon.
abuseI loved it! hehe
Return to Top