 Galinda-girl 2008-02-01 . chapter 1I dont know if you already wrote that they met the Cullens, but I just don't think it will make sense to have 3 different sets of characters, for one plot. Besides, Twilight is NOT the best book in the world, but THE PRINCESS BRIDE. There was a movie, but the book is 100x better. Read it! |
 ShadowCatMage13 2008-01-24 . chapter 1I am going to critique this chapter. So it would be best for you not to take any offense at anything I say: simply consider it.
Your concept of clones is an interesting one. We know from the third book that they do have clones... and it has potential. I recommend no cross over. Cross overs are aweful; they don't work at all. I have loathe cross overs.
The problems with this chapter:
the names of the clones are very confusing- most start with the same letter, some have the difference of a letter... is Iggy or Izzy speaking? Andi or Andy? In this case, I think you give the readers to much credit for their reading skills.
Why does Max think they might be clones?
A few times you stated the obvious, which is giving your readers to LITTLE credit. The description of Twilight was not necessary- a person who has read it knows the cover (and author), and unless a person is culturaly (sp) deprived, they know what the cover of Twilight looks like. Or they can look it up. There are more, but I am pressed for time.
Why would Andi steal Twilight if she has already read it? And if she's a fan, she would realize that stealing the book is stealing from Stephenie Meyer. I do not like the concept of shoplifting books.
You need to check your grammar a bit, such as comma usage, spelling, etc. Make sure you know the meaning of a word before you put it in the story ("inevitable" means predictable, unavoidable, expected).
As I said, do not take offense. I focus on advising on the negative parts of a fic because they are what stands out most (back when I wrote fanfics, I made such mistakes gallore). I am interested to see where this fic is going. Keep writing, you can only get better!
Note: Do as I say, not as I do; this review has not been proof-read and most likely has many spelling/grammatical/airhead mistakes. |