|
|
| Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search | Login Register Extras |
| arimel 2008-05-13 ch 3, | abuseI *really* like this story so far. The way that you have the interaction between Tim and Curly regarding girls just rings really true to me--I think a lot of stories fail to address the whole rivalry/opinions about girls/boys that siblings get, and I like way that you've handled it. Tricia seems really fragile, but in a not-unbelievable way. In the last chapter when she cried, I really felt that that was an appropriate response that anyone would give in that situation--a certain amount of self-pity, and a lot of unhappiness, but nothing completely ridiculous, and I think it's believable ESPECIALLY for a teenage girl, that they wouldn't necessarily haul off and punch someone. This is actually my favorite story that you've written. :) |
| iLikeToWatch 2008-04-23 ch 3, anon. | abuseAs you already know (you've got great reviews :) this is really well-written and overall, well-done. There are just a few things that hit me though. I don't find it very realistic that all those 'rumours' about Tricia would actually follow her out of high school. Furthermore, I can't really see Curly insulting her for it. The way you've described him (determined not to be a virgin when he gets into highschool, etc.), he seems more like the kind of person that would see her as this great opportunity, rather than some slut! It'd also be nice if you gave Tricia some attitude. Though I feel for her in her plight, it's more a feeling of pity, than sympathizing. I can't see any chemistry between her and Curly. Anyhow, to end on a good note, I enjoyed reading this. You have a great writing style that makes the story interesting and easy to read. Good job. :) |
| spooky ain't it 2008-04-05 ch 3, | abuseaha. so tricia has a boyfriend now. (thought maybe not for long.) good chapter. :] spook |
| NittanyLizard 2008-04-04 ch 3, | abuseAnd in one swoop, Ron gets screwed over by Tricia's past :D. Nice job, great chapter. Poor Tricia, what an awful experience to have in high school. Not too far off the mark, though. Every man for himself. I won't make too many comments because I'm too far behind in everything else to have a good enough sense of who everybody is and what happens along the timeline. But so far on its own, I think I'm following. And even if I'm not, I'm enjoying the story. Signing off, the bus is almost here. Liz |
| NittanyLizard 2008-04-04 ch 2, | abuseYou are way too fast an updater for me, but I am struggling to catch up here ;). I absolutely love the humor in all of this, because it's subtle enough to be real - doesn't feel funny to them, but to somebody looking into their heads from the outside it really is. Curly's experience with Elaine was the best. Great job describing it. And then at the end, it all gets pulled together with Tricia's unexpected (to Curly) reaction. You do a fantastic job building tension. On to next chapter before the bus gets here . . . |
| roswellachick 2008-04-03 ch 3, | abusePoor tricia, H.S was horrid for her awwe Ron does sound like a good guy |
| frizzyhairedloon 2008-04-03 ch 3, | abusehooray, you updated! You know I really love this story and this couple so I am very glad at the fact that you updated. Isn't there a Ron in one of your other fics? I think I remember a guy with a mustache who is supposedly like a bad dude. But I'm probably WAY off here, so forget I said that. Anyways, I'm glad to see that the feelings of love have resurfaced! They are so totally meant for each other, its hilarious how perfect they are for each other but they just don't notice it and keep denying themselves, thinking that it will never happen. You've really made me hate Ray more, I'm not sure if that was your intention though. I always end up feeling bad for Curly, even though he would probably hate that. Why is it that the Shepard boys dig girls that always look scared? Like Tim likes Ruby who supposedly looks scared a lot, and apparently Tricia does too. So once again, thanks for updating with a wonderful chapter and please continue your magnificent writing. Please update with another chapter soon! |
| xocrazililkelox 2008-04-03 ch 3, | abusePoor Trica she needs to get over this Curly thing.Even though i'm sure we all had a Curly in our lives, lol.Pretty please update soon . PS- I liked all the little stuff with Ray and Angela.Nice set up for Holding.You can all read sense the downfall of the Shepard gang. |
| Fosterchild 2008-04-03 ch 3, | abuseI don't know when i stared liking Curly. And even though he's been a jerk in this most of the time ... this story is making me like the guy. You're bringing out the sympathetic side. |
| Nelle07 2008-04-03 ch 3, | abuseI love it! I really do! I hope she'd get to defend herself! So Ron is her boyfriend! |
| C.E.A 2008-03-17 ch 1, anon. | abusePLEASE UPDATE SOON! I LOVE YOUR STORY! THANK YOU. |
| Nelle07 2008-03-13 ch 2, | abusehahah!! I love it! Now he is going to feel really bad and she's going to ignore him! hahah! |
| SisterCat144 2008-03-09 ch 2, | abuseplz update this again soon! =D |
| soda's girl 2008-03-09 ch 2, | abuseaww... its nice to know that even though guys like that are tough they dont push girls to the crying limit... amazing! Update soon! |
| Big Town Avenue 2008-03-07 ch 2, | abuseWhoa, Curly, a little harsh. I am glad he's kind of surprised that she's crying and he seems to feel a little bad about it. I love Curly's pov. I never, ever see it, so it's kind of refreshing, especially since everybody seems to think of Curly as dumb. lol I love that he's a virgin and it's just about killing him. I can see him being really upset over the fact because of all the stories he hears from the guys, but you have to wonder how many of their stories are actually true. |