Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: What If
LilRicki
2008-02-13 . chapter 1
Interesting choices for all of their outcomes. :-)

-LilRicki (aka Pansy Chubb)
sparklyshimmer2010
2008-02-07 . chapter 1
that was very nice! very interesting and so well written! you got the characters perfectly! sad thw way it ended before the epilogue, at least with rodney.
but it was very very good!
Stargate Groupie
2008-02-07 . chapter 1
Very well written! Poor Teyla and Rodney, things didn’t go to well for them in the AU world! I liked how everyone’s lives were different and yet not so different. Great job!
trecebo
2008-02-07 . chapter 1
You paint a bleak picture, but I feel it could be a possible life for our intrepid heroes... Very well done, with all the detail. Loved the bit with Carson. I mean, who doesn't love Carson?
faldo
2008-02-07 . chapter 1
Thank goodness they found the ZPM! Enjoyed this fic thanks.
A Hopless Romantic
2008-02-06 . chapter 1
E! And ah! So sad and so true and so happy, i really liked this keep it up.
Stealth Dragon
2008-02-06 . chapter 1
Very excellent. I like that you made their pasts complicated, some so-so, some bad but getting better, and some just bad (as in poor McKay's case.)

I also find it interesting the past you gave Sheppard as it seems the biggest alteration. I would have thought he would still be in the military - maybe with a lower rank because of his black mark - just not in Antarctica.
TheNaggingCube
2008-02-06 . chapter 1
Bloody sad and wonderful and so horribly believable both in the scary sad what if AU and the real (snicker) 'verse
Return to Top