 ArmorBlade 2009-09-18 . chapter 1An excellent excellent exploration piece.
Like how you left out any detail whom Negi may have actually ended up with, yet involve Chao, and Eva's passing unkown The relation between Setsuna and Eva was also very appropriate and the moods played were right somehow, complex but comforting if ever they were left to be the only ones.
I was wondering if someone had made a fic concerning Setsuna after Konoka's time. You did well, though I would think she'd think back on that detail more - then again maybe she does think alot of Konoka with all her free time, or too far back now even to remember how much it hurt to think back on it at all... |
 kieu 2009-08-30 . chapter 1sorry for the late review ;P
i really liked your story! it's beautifully written & everything flowed so nicely that i couldn't stop reading
the angst was almost perfect
i especially loved the ending, very well done
hope you keep up the great work ;) |
 intangibleINK 2009-08-05 . chapter 1Soo pretty! It was beautiful. Beautifully sad.
There's not much I can really criticize... Spelling, grammar, punctuation were fine.
It was really good. I liked it. ;D |
 khanto 2009-07-17 . chapter 1Beautiful...
I shall submit a more in depth review later...
My god, i'm crying...
Bravo! Bravo! |
 An Idiot 2009-07-15 . chapter 1Jaw droppingly brilliant. Amazingly so. Though, I'm sure Chao's meddling must've made some different and/or awareness that Negi could've used to prevent he future. Or maybe it was jus that meddling thatade the world like that in some sort of time paradox. Ugh, brain hurts...
Again, brilliant story. Bravo. :) |
 Chisame.Yuri-con 2009-07-11 . chapter 1Its really saddening that setsuna is always left to loneliness.
But i love the fact that they manage to still live and move on even after having a wasted life.
i can relate so much to the characters.
*thumbs up* one of my favorites. very classic!! |
 tjal 2009-06-27 . chapter 1I think the story really started to take off when Evangeline met Chao but on the other hand, I think the beginning forms a necessary component and contrast to the later Eva. The fact that Setsuna was left behind was heartbreaking. But, maybe while Chao failed, Eva still managed to secure her goals and the ending is more uplifting than I thought it would be. Congrats on a very well written story. |
 Sunbath 2009-03-06 . chapter 1I have probably never read a fanfic as well written as this one; in the respect that i could easily view this as a side story for canon.
It also helps that the story contains minimal amounts typos and grammatical errors ^^
All in all, i have enjoyed this story immensly and i thank you for having written, it really made my day ;)
Sun |
 ichigolynn 2008-08-25 . chapter 1;_; No so sad. *cries* NO *doesn't want to spoil* NO WHY
*ahem* Good story by the way ! *thumbs up* B-but..NO
[x] favorites |
 mgcbs 2008-08-19 . chapter 1Interesting to say the least. This one is a Konosetsu fan through and through but only recently realised that in the circumstances involving Konoka's rejection and/or death, then Evasetsu could be a possibility and they really would be everlasting. This one always wondered how they would function, an long since suffering Eva paired with a very emotionally fragile Setsuna and this one thought that this interpretation of their relationship was a realistic if a little angst filled. There were tender moments, as much as a scathing Eva could manage, and there were depressing moments with seemingly no happy future at all for the heroines.
Introduction of Chao and time-travelling fitted in nicely, although Eva not returning was a heartbreaking moment - possibly expected, given the tone of the whole piece. This rather dull one found the ending ambiguous but on a good note, since it could signify the complete end or whole new beginning for the wretched hanyo of a tragic heroine.
This one much prefers happier endings with small trials for both Eva and Setsuna, both deserve happier times after the mess they have been through so far - however this one did enjoy the fanfiction, it was down-to-earth and sobering if nothing else.
This unworthy one thanks you for writing this piece and apologises for not reviewing immediately... this one needed some 'fluff' to get out of the dark remains of the world that you described most intricately.
(from Mana-san on Mahora forums) |
 Nini62223 2008-08-05 . chapter 1Great ! It was... fantastic !
I... I'm almost crying there.
Really thank you ! |
 forego 2008-05-25 . chapter 1beautifully writte and such a heart breaking piece. |
 Little Wolf 713 2008-05-13 . chapter 1because you sent me a pm ;]
its honestly really really great.
like, oh my, it made me think [in a good way]
and the ending was...too good.
im not a big fan of angst, but this was...wow. ahahaa
[btw, sorry i didnt review before. i was lazy.]
xP |
 buschi 2008-05-11 . chapter 1 *clapclapclap*...huhh that was something entirely different than i expected...°_°
at first i was like "what the heck?!?",but just because it was something new to read...the concept was really intrigueing and i thought "great,i want to read more!"..although the content was at some pionts a bit off for the fast understanding,however the characters were portrait in an interesting way and i liked that too...^^
it was nice to read this story and you could tell that you put a lot effort in to the developing!!
great work!!XD*
mfg B. |
 Cloverfield 2008-04-20 . chapter 1It's an opus, alright.
Kami.
I hated it a little, like I always hate things that are so much better than what I can achieve. Jealous, thou art Cloverfield.
It's ** awesome. I liked it entirely too much for someone who says she doesn't like angst (even if she writes it, very very badly) and I'm sure it will have me thinking for a very, very long time.
I've seen, what, three whole stories about the future and about Chao. And this just totally blows them out of the water.
It's melancholic. Dark and despairing but still disgustingly hopeful and you just know this is what the world would be like. And could very well still be like, should Chao fail. I make no sense.
Chao is just right, Setsuna is raw and Evangeline is horribly perfect. How many ends of worlds has Eva seen, after all?
I'm envious. It's brilliant.
Thankyou for writing it. |