|Reviews for I Saw My Lady Weep|
| Margaret 12/23/12 . chapter 2
Wow... this whole confession in front of the entire Great Hall? Seems a tad out of character...
On the other hand, I really like the flow of your writing and am going to read more :D
| littledozziebug 10/22/12 . chapter 32
woh that was depressing. Thanks for sharing your story!
| mab70 10/15/12 . chapter 32
Well done. Though I was not ready to make the jump from pre-marriage to 60 some years later.
| Slaidback 10/12/12 . chapter 32
Cheers. Good story.
| Slaidback 10/12/12 . chapter 9
This is a good story so far, apart from one thing and its a mistake more than one harry potter fic makes- ron & harry did not do muggle studies, if it was hermoine talking about a muggle author than fine or hermione said... then no problem. I did appreciate the point you were trying to get across however.
| jg13145 6/4/12 . chapter 32
Brilliant story! It was amazing and I cried reading the last chapter Just can't imagine Harry,Ginny, or any else being gone.
| crazy-wee-cat 5/7/12 . chapter 32
That was an amazing story! I loved all of it ) I thought everyone in the story was really in character, and I thought that the storyline was really realistic of what it would have been like after the war. Mrs Weasley, especially, was very in character and I thought that would have been exactly how she would have reacted. The ending was so sad, but really appropriate, and sort of beautiful at the same time. Thanks for writing it! D
| blewis61 4/22/12 . chapter 32
I just finished power reading through the story, which in of itself should tell you how much I enjoyed it. It was a well written story and kept me engrossed the entire time.
That said I must say that starting with the accident it completely threw me for a loop. The accident forward could have been it's own story and would have made more sense to me I think. It was has if you started out writing missing 19 story and then did a story on the depth of their love instead. Granted, both were good, and they did tie into each other, but I just was caught totally off guard, and truthfully I really want to see the continuation of the story you began telling about Harry and Ginny. Did he become a successful auror (you elude to the fact that he did but nothing concrete), did she become a professional quidditch player? I don't know anything lol, I feel like I need a fan fic written about your fan fic now :).
Of course the upswing to all of this is that your story was enjoyable enough that I actually am sad to see it end and thus am wanting more on it :). Thanks for the great read, I will be looking forward to reading some of your other work.
| mialuvtwilight 12/4/11 . chapter 32
| Epeefencer 8/23/11 . chapter 32
Just finished reading this story and I really liked how you ended it. Not many take the story to Harry and Ginny's death. Very bold of you. It ended the way I think that Harry and Ginny would end up, going together on the next journey. I loved how you had Ginny waiting for Harry.
I found the jump from the previous chapter to the end kind of lacking because of all the things you left out. Yes they were implied but I think you could have touched on them.
All in all I liked it very much,
Thanks for sharing,
| Dodos-r-not-extinct 7/5/11 . chapter 32
Beautiful. Oh so very beautiful and heart-warming. An excellent continuation of the Harry Potter books, filling in the gaps that I'm sure we all wanted to know. And the true ending, the end of the Boy Who Lived. A delicately handled tale woven with finesse, well done!
(Can you tell I liked it? XD)
| AbstractDreamLander 6/13/11 . chapter 32
So sad, so sweet!
I love this story so much. The ending was especially lovely.
Great job on this!
| Lindenmc 12/20/10 . chapter 18
I think your story is absolutely brilliant, and your writing is wonderful.
| my.mum.hid.my.hogwarts.letter 10/22/10 . chapter 32
i can see that this story is not a recent one but i just only finnished then for the 1st time then!
You had me crying in this last chapter it was so unexpected and real if you get what i mean
right now i have that sick feeling in my stomach that happens when something in the story happens but you can relate it to real life...
this is an amazing story and if anyone didnt like it id say they would be out of their minds !
| Narnia Lucy 6/21/10 . chapter 8
In this chapter, the funniest phrase was
"I'm perfectly serious… Sirius? Serious… he always hated that pun…" Harry raised the bottle of firewhisky. "We forgot to toast Sirius. He got one of these manky medals tonight, so let's toast Sirius. So here's to Sirius." He took a slug from the bottle and passed it to Percy. "What was I shay… saying? Oh yeah… I think you're a bit drunk, George. George."