This was a clever little fic. I'd like to see more of Carlisle's exploits, even if we don't get to meet other historical figures.

clever...

Carlisle and Ben Franklin! Very cool ;-)

Ha! Carlisle rubbing elbows with Benjamin Franklin. I love it when history gets thrown into the mix of the Cullens' past. Makes it see more believable. More alive. Nice work!

wow! how historically perfect...of course carlisle would have met several historical figures in all his years! it was greatly portrayed and so much in character...

i love your stories as always...

so thanks for carlisle and mr. franklin (when he was silence dogwood!)

lol!

Very, Very nice.

I'm so glad I knew who Silence Dogood was before the end! :D National Treasure helped me with that one... and a little bit of history class. :D But I loved that Carlisle got really upset at Benjamin Franklin! Haha! That was great!

Yours truly,

Amelia Bedelia

Haha that was awesome!

I loved how you added that little twist at the end, I certainly wasn't expecting it.

It's so cool to get a little glimpse into what Carlisle might have seen/been like :p

haha, that was so good! and it made me laugh

That is so good! It really is exceptional and i loved the twist into the past. Great Job as always! ]]

oh bravo! that was fantastic - i didn't even guess who it was meant to be until you said. I loved that.

I love the ending!

Wow, wow, wow.

You are so imaginative. And this is perfect! I can tell you worked hard! How do you know so many archaic words? Really, it's amazing.

Wow...very, very clever! :) I like Carlisle stories, too!

I really enjoyed this story. Its never occured to me to think more about Carlisle, but this certainly got me going. Very well done, good work.