Ohh wow! The emotions, so well written. I love this!

Good job :D

xXx

Wow. The drama. The emotion. This was a good concept, and I feel that with some revising and elaborating it would be made even better. I revised one of my own, and now that it's done, I am pretty glad with it. I feel bad for Shadow, being played like that. Poor guy...

N.R.

beautiful and angry. I love it. Shadow, you the man!

Nice job. You should probably make a sequal where Shadow finds someone new.

Whoa! What a happy ending! XD

It sucked that they didn't get back together in the end but it built up some great tension for the fic.

I loved this fic even though Shadow dumped Rouge.

Oh! You should make a sequel to this. Maybe you can have Shadow try to or kill Knuckles. Now that would be interesting.
Just a little idea if you had a hard time thinking of something else to write. .

Hey! Great story I luved it! This story kind of reminds me of a song called Welcome Home by Coheed and Cambria. Maybe its because I've never heard Your Love Is A Lie or cuz I just listened to it. Anyway, It was a GREAT story!

Aw... poor Shadow... and Rouge.

I love how you make Sonic and Shadow friends... for no reason, really.
Love it! -faves-

Aw I feel bad for Shadow
Oh well at least he has Amy now XD

Great emotion

Nice job!