Wow...brilliant, really really nice job with, might i say, such a strange starting point? God, brilliant!

Lovely. Just...lovely.

I really, really shouldn't have clicked on your name. Your stuff is wonderful, and mostly stuff I love...Doctor Who, Lord of the Rings, BSG. I'll be reading a while, I think!

As they say in badly spelled fanfic: ur grate!

Fascinating play on words throughout all of this, I love it!

brilliant. Absolutely brilliant piece of writing! I love it! Mucho loves!

A little confusing for me, I blame the hour in which I read, but gracefully written none the less.

Has anyone ever told you what a bloody fantastic writer you are? I sure as hell hope so, because I seem to have run out of words to express it myself. That was beautiful ;_;

Aw, this is fantastic. So sweet, and I'm not even really that fond of the Doctor and Rose. Not because of Rose herself, she's brilliant, but because everyone compares Martha to her. Not Donna, cos she's just way too different. But you managed to have Martha as awesome as she is, and still have Doctor/Rose, so great meas out to you!

Very beautiful piece, wonderfully vague and descriptive all at one. You're right creative - amazing work all round.

Very nice. I love how well you tie in so many parts of the Doctor's past. Another excellent story as usual.
-AutumnxAngel

*sigh*, another addition to Doomed Fic. Why is seemingly every other story on this site a strong candidate for the place?

Wonderful twist on a little annoying snag in the language department! I love it when people take little details like that and make something of them.

Christ, can't you quit it with the crappy reunion stories YET?

Wow. This is brilliant; very deep, makes you think about the plot, the situations, the characters etc. Especially like how youve brought in characters from every era of Doctor Who, and how it all seems to link together- the beginning and the end I mean. And I lke the thought that Rose now knows (in a way) more about him than any other companion (except Reinette and the telepathy incident) Very nice, it's a great read! Well done, I love it! :D

Beautiful one-shot; it's verging on poetry in some places. I especially like the way the begining and the end tie together.

holy **. this is an EXCEPTIONAL story. first of all, charming plot idea, ha for the bad Norwegian and i love that you had rose have a pretty boy tell her. love the fairy tale motif you have throughout, because, well, it just may be the best and is one of those things that we completely go back to all the time in writing, particularly fitting doctor who with its big bad wolf and gingerbread house parallel universes. you really know your canon-background, too, and it shows- i'm not familiar with all the old characters, except through fanfiction really, but you give a really strong sense of them in the whole 'he remembers... always his' section, which is pretty much just phenomenal. seeing how you managed to pin down the qualities that can really define rose and martha (wonder and warm, craft and security... oh, and Donna.), i suspect you probably nailed all of them.
i think my favorite part was the 'jackie. wait. jackie?' the image of him almost being able to feel the time passed in the years on rose's skin is also a brilliant touch and so Time Lord-y. also, fricking incredible job handling a sex scene, and so doctor and rose, esp. the talking, love the image of the memories- another- and all the things he tells her, and what he thinks about them, seem like what he would really think. which, imho, seems damn hard to do. so congrats. great, great closing and use of his 'quite right.' so, in case you couldn't tell, I loved this. most excellent job.