|Reviews for I love you' is never going to be enough|
| ginny evans 1/1/11 . chapter 1
aaaww so very sweet!
| Quidditch Is Cooler Than You 1/5/10 . chapter 1
Beautiful. I love how you captured James' unknown side of him. This was an incredible read, I'm glad I clicked on it :)
| serindraxx 12/9/08 . chapter 1
aw, *wipes away happy tears* i loved it! so sweet!
| thestralwhisperer 5/24/08 . chapter 1
Lovely story, I really enjoyed reading it
| The Luna Complex 3/16/08 . chapter 1
I know I have to leave a a review telling you how wonderful this is, but can't put into words why I liked it so much. It felt real, not like the shallow love you find in most fics. It's how I've always pictured Lily and James. I think you've captured them really well.
| summersgirl2526 3/15/08 . chapter 1
that was so sweet I loved James's proposal!
| hpobsessedrissa 3/13/08 . chapter 1
Amazing. There was no big production, no fancy words...it just felt so pure and perfect and right. I absolutely loved it, especially this:
"He didn’t know what was prompting all of this. Was it her? Why hadn’t it happened before? She had always been pretty. Yet now she was beautiful beyond belief. She had always been smart, funny, witty and wonderful. But now she was so perfect, even her imperfections were something of a wonder."
Marvelous, one of the best proposal stories I've ever read :)
| Qwertatious 3/13/08 . chapter 1
That, my dear friend, was absolutely horrific.
You know damn well that you can produce so much better than that trash. In fact, it was so below your standard that when I finished reading, I didn't know whether to stab you with a poisoned fork for writing all that, or to stab myself for painstakingly reading it to the very last word.
...Hey, you do know that I'm joking, right? XD Haha! I LOVE doing that...
Anyways, onto the real review... :p I really love the way you manage to convey all of James' emotions so clearly to the reader. Christ, Rhea, you're freakin' glowing with brilliance - it's even shining out of your ass. And that's SCARY for us mortals!
Watch the grammar and spelling, though - I spotted a few mistakes!
Your darling, lovable friend who is feeling suspiciously mischievous,
| zeppelincloud 3/13/08 . chapter 1
absolutely brilliant. Sublime. Beautiful.
| kitty-re 3/13/08 . chapter 1
So cute and beautifully written :)
| Solitary12 3/12/08 . chapter 1
Very good, best engagement story I've read. Write more :P
| LoonyLuna127 3/12/08 . chapter 1
That was really, really good, and I thoroughly enjoyed it. 10/10
| novella07 3/12/08 . chapter 1
wow, that was better than any other engagement scenes ive seen of lily and james, that was absolutely amazing, and well written, keep it up!
| IvyClimbing 3/12/08 . chapter 1
so good, and so cute. you're a wonderful writer, i love what you said and the way you said it. keep it up!
| Confoundment 3/12/08 . chapter 1
That was unbelievable. That was literally one of the best things I have ever read. :D