 WildCroconaw 2009-10-29 . chapter 16Wow! Thanks to Lucky's skill at the Whack-a-mon game amy was able to get a porygon |
 Eveser 2009-10-27 . chapter 16That is some skill Lucky has. That makes his name very ironic. |
 WildCroconaw 2009-09-28 . chapter 15i love Leviathan's names! it so suits the gigantic pokemon! |
 WildCroconaw 2009-09-03 . chapter 12Will Amy make? She's got to make it...right? |
 WildCroconaw 2009-09-03 . chapter 5I was bitting my nails through the whole chapter. there were times that i thought Lucky and Arrow were goners.
I really think Amy should open her own gym after she is done with her journey |
 Iced Perfection 2009-07-05 . chapter 1Though I'm tempted to say exactly what you said to me back to your own story, I won't. Instead, I'll show you what a critique should be like.
I think that you're using a lot of great descriptions, but the beginning seems a bit slow - more dialogue would help. I realize it's just showing us what is happening, but despite that, I think that it could stand a little dialogue to break it up.
One thing I noticed is that Nurse Joy says that the Growlithe is, once in its Pokeball, in need of a trainer since it cannot be released. I was under the impression that they *could* be released. (See episode "Bye Bye, Butterfree" for reference, as well as the games where you are given an option to release them.)
There are a few small problems in dealing with grammar, punctuation, etc, but overall it is written pretty well, I have to admit.
Then there is the Skarmory...Skarmory are human-sized, no? Winona's is, at least. Maybe it's special? I don't know. But in any case, Skarmory doesn't seem like it could fit in Amy's bag, unless it's like one of those magic ones in Harry Potter? That could explain it...
Battle scenes are pretty full of descriptions and I don't see anything that is majorly wrong with them.
I'm only on chapter five, but at the moment I have prior obligations. I will be returning shortly to finish my critique. Ta! |
 Kai-Chan94 2009-07-03 . chapter 9LOL! This chapter, although short, was hilarious! I hope to read your update soon! |
 Kai-Chan94 2009-07-03 . chapter 8YAY! I have a Tyranitar on my team of Pokemon. I really like your story! |
 WildCroconaw 2008-12-20 . chapter 4I like how amy came up with Arrow's name. A Skarmory's feathers are as sharp as an arrow so it work out perfectly.
I hope she does well in the doubles tournemnet |
 WildCroconaw 2008-12-19 . chapter 3The rain was expressing bailey's feelings |
 my-little-starr 2008-12-19 . chapter 8Another amazing chapter. Update soon. |
 my-little-starr 2008-12-06 . chapter 7Oh poor Tyranitar! I am glad tat Amy got a Larvitar but I wish it wasn't under those circumstances. poor little thing. |
 WildCroconaw 2008-10-04 . chapter 1I don't think it would be right for Amy to take Napper away from his mom. I think she will do much better with the growlithe she saved.
I love the idea of the heal ball! |
 hi there flamingo 2008-05-26 . chapter 6Eioah!~ drama. drama. drama. I bet leigh will be amy's battling partner for round three, that shall be interesting! Anyway, great chapter! SO happy to see the update! i think i died for a while after that long wait! |
 Lady of DarkFire 2008-05-24 . chapter 6cooll,a new friend. I like him, he seems nice. I hope he ends up not being a grunt for team rocket or some thing. I like hows he's a bird trainer, you don't see those that ofteten in fics, can't wait to see how Amy does in her next battle. |