 Amethyst Asheryn 2008-09-29 . chapter 1I don't think I've reviewed before, so here we go:
I *love* this. It's so sad, and haunting, and good. I love how, over time, Alex loses that rebellious streak that makes him sign "Alex Rider." it's gradual, not too sudden ... It's really good.
the scene with Blunt and Byrne was in past tense, while the rest was in present. That's pretty much my only major qualm with this - the tense switch. But it was only for that one scene, and then you switched back to present. Personally, I like it more in present.
"The next time he's asked to sign something, he writes Alex Sarov." - Awesome ending. Like I said, I love how he gradually breaks down - from being Alex Rider, to calling Sarov "father" in Russian, to finally signing 'Alex Sarov.' The ending line ended it with this sad, haunting feeling, at least for me. Poor Alex.
I also like how you don't over-describe Alex's whipping, but you do manage to make us feel sorry for him. And he's so in character there, the way he tries to hold it together and doesn't just go to pieces.
"He can feel them both, and wonders, vaguely, if there is blood soaking his t-shirt. Or if his shirt has simply been destroyed." I didn't like the flow of these parts. I think it might sound better as:
"He can feel them both, and wonders, vaguely, if there is blood soaking his t-shirt or if it has simply been destroyed." I think it sounds better combined into one sentence.
"He both wishes that the General will hurry up, or decide he is finished." I think this would sound better as:
"He wishes that the General will either hurry up, or decide he is finished." The 'both' doesn't really fit.
"When it’s over, he stays hunched over." You used 'over' twice, and that really bugs me. Maybe substitute the first 'over' for 'through,' or 'done,' or some such.
"That's going to be a pain to clean up ..." I love this, simply because in some odd, twisted way, it's so Alex. For some reason, considering his circumstances, I can really see him saying this - even if it's just the first thing to mind.
Okay. This review is way, way too long. Just know that, apart from the stuff I pointed out above, I really love this piece. Thanks for writing,
Ashe |
 Insarai Arys 2008-06-29 . chapter 1Wow. That is really just a 'wow' fic...I really really want to know more, but sometimes it's best to let the reader imagine more...Agh. Now I've tempted myself with thinking of more Alex...For sooth, I should be stonger! But he's so yummy even when he's being 'emo'...
Oh well, back to my fantasies of Alex and others. See you there, if you're lucky... |