Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: The Scouring of the Shire: Saruman's Revenge - Page 1 of 2
King Caspian the Seafarer
2009-06-27 . chapter 10
Poor, poor Saruman. Even though he was a villain, it's never satisfying for a fic to end in death. Oh well. There I go, getting pensive and philisophic. ;) You did a great job writing a book-verse account of Saruman's Revenge. ;) I'm glad it's finished. You do write villains so horribly well, you know. ;)

Lion be with you,

KC
KireKhane Faerring
2009-05-09 . chapter 10
Intriguing, very intriguing. Well done.
fanofisengard99
2009-05-01 . chapter 10
that was really good. i really like how you know what saruman is thinking.
QueenSwanWhite
2009-04-28 . chapter 10
Wow! That was a really well done ending!
Great job!

~QueenSwanWhite~
fanofisengard99
2009-03-21 . chapter 3
you write well, but you underestimated the voice of saruman. in the book, his voice was supposed to seem wise and reasonable even though his words might not be. therefore, the hobbits shouldn't have protested against saruman's voice so easily.
S'mana
2009-01-14 . chapter 9
Saruman is such an interesting and tragic character. You've done a great job writing Saruman and delving into his mind.

"The big tree was hard to bring to earth, for it roots went deep."
That reminded me of that line from FOTR "The trees are strong, it's roots run deep."

I hated that this part of the book wasn't filmed.

"My victory was almost complete."
I don't think he'll have victory, since I feel the final chapter will be his demise. Or will his fate be changed? Hmm..
QueenSwanWhite
2008-12-03 . chapter 9
AHH! What will happen next?
I suppose I will just have to wait.
Well done!
~QueenSwanWhite~
QueenSwanWhite
2008-12-03 . chapter 8
Ah I didn't see that coming although I suppose I should've.
I must get to the next chapter for I'm anxious to find out what happens next.
~QueenSwanWhite~
QueenSwanWhite
2008-12-03 . chapter 7
*shudders*
I would hate to be Wormtongue...he had such and evil master.
~QueenSwanWhite~
QueenSwanWhite
2008-12-03 . chapter 6
I feel so sorry for the poor hobbits! :)
Very well done and very good!
~QueenSwanWhite~
QueenSwanWhite
2008-12-03 . chapter 5
Very good! And now I shall read on...
~QueenSwanWhite~
QueenSwanWhite
2008-12-03 . chapter 4
The poor hobbits! Can you imagine them not being able
to do all of those things? :)
~QueenSwanWhite~
QueenSwanWhite
2008-12-03 . chapter 3
Very good!:)
Sharkey...very funny!
~QueenSwanWhite~
QueenSwanWhite
2008-12-03 . chapter 2
Oh! Very good! I must move
on to the next chapter to see
what happens next!
~QueenSwanWhite~
QueenSwanWhite
2008-12-03 . chapter 1
Very intriguing! Good thing you've already posted the other chapters. Don't know if I could've waited. :)
~QueenSwanWhite~
Return to Top