Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: The Sorting - Page 1 of 14
ramaya
2009-12-29 . chapter 16
Hi! This was a really awesome story, and it sometimes just made me laugh out loud, so keep up the good work!

xx
PS: I'm 199. That's awesome.
Black Mirror
2009-12-09 . chapter 15
Love the way you wrote Dominique!
Drusilla Braun
2009-11-09 . chapter 16
This is really good. Great job.
Sean Mulligan
2009-08-18 . chapter 16
You should have put some one of the potters or Weasley's in a house other then Gryffindor. Maybe even Slytherin.
Twinkie
2009-08-11 . chapter 16
I love how you've given everyone their own individual personality's, but I think it might have been more realistic if more people ended up somewhere not expected, or at least have them wanting to go into a house not JUST because that's where everyone in their family's been. Also, I was a little disappointed when EVERYONE got into a house that one or both of their parents were in. Not a single one so far got a house where neither of their parents were in that house first. I think it would have been more realistic if someone, ANYONE was sorted into a different house. Also, random note, no ones gotten into Hufflepuff yet. Overall, I like how you've given life to characters that were only briefly mentioned in the books, and some that weren't mentioned at all.:]
FancyNewWeasley
2009-04-08 . chapter 6
My parents said I was planned...” That wasn’t even funny. What’s wrong with me?

Hahahahahaha!
5redroses
2009-04-07 . chapter 16
Well i think it was time someone asked that. Go Roxy!
sarabara
2009-03-27 . chapter 4
"What if I get put in Slytherin, and my Uncle Ron dies of shock? What if my dad does? Or my grandma? What if the sorting hat manages to wipe out my whole family?"

that legit made me lol and my family all looked at me like i was deranged, laughing at a laptop :] cant wait to read the rest!
Masen
2009-03-10 . chapter 16
I love it! You are obviously a very empathic person, because you've come up with so many possibilities of how everyone would feel in their various circumstances, and i've found myself thinking deeply about each of their experiences.
I'm glad you stuck to the most likely sorting results for everyone, rather than mixing them up everywhere just for the sake of variety, as i've read many times before in these sort of fics.
I think Albus' and Louis' were my favorites, bless 'em...
Dodger Gilmore
2009-02-05 . chapter 16
Great ending to the story. I had never thought of any of them asking him about Voldemort, but I think that was a brilliant idea, and it was even more perfect that it came in the last chapter too. Great reason for her to end up in Gryffindor (and I'm really glad she did, because she and Lucy did need to be together!). This has been an amazing story, and I hate to see it end, but you've done a wonderful job with it!
Dodger Gilmore
2009-02-05 . chapter 15
I really enjoyed this. Love the voice you gave Dominique, and her reflections on Victoire - and the hat, and how she thought it might smell. Kind of funny. So sorry this has taken a while for me to get to. Again. I'll read on now, though, and just say that this was great and no, it didn't show that this came difficult for you.
NellieNotMolly
2009-01-25 . chapter 16
Really cute! I felt a little nervous for Roxy myself! I now want to go back and read them all again! :-)
silverbirch
2009-01-25 . chapter 16
That was a lovely one to end with.

Thank you, I've really enjoyed this story. It took a great deal of skill to write 16 chapters on the same subject but make each one unique.
LilysMommy
2009-01-25 . chapter 16
Wow.
I love that Roxy had it in her to question the hats decisions on Voldemort. Kudos to you, Roxy!
blackcricket
2009-01-25 . chapter 4
albus' imagination is way too wide... dies because of shock? lolz...
Return to Top