Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Dumb Books - Page 1 of 2
Kaizoku-Taii
2009-11-08 . chapter 3
/very/ effective. Especially chapter two when Rodney was really begining to...well...die, I suppose. Actually made my heart clench slightly. Very effective.

Also, the explination of those coughs which you can't stop cause you need to cough, but which are just completely useless cause you don't have the energy anymore and your chest hurts so much... I know exactly what you meant atthat, and it was written well.

Thanks for posting

Kai x
Whirlwind421
2009-04-15 . chapter 3
I loved it!!
x Varda x
2008-12-27 . chapter 3
Poor Rodney! He always gets the short end of the stick in your stories :O
Not only did he nearly die, but he lost his precious books...
Excellent story (as usual!)
Korilian
2008-11-14 . chapter 1
No! Don't burn the rosseta stone! It's an imaginary book in an imaginary universe and still this hurts me.
msdarque
2008-09-09 . chapter 3
I loved reading the story. Interesting point when Rodney couldn't speak.. LOL Excellent!
Lots of stars!
HlysComment
2008-09-03 . chapter 3
*applauds enthusiastically*

Incredible story. I absolutely loved it!
HlysComment
2008-09-03 . chapter 1
So far, so good. This story is really drawing me in.
Jinxauthor Mel
2008-05-08 . chapter 3
Good Lord, I think I might hurt for that loss as much as Rodney does. But I really really like your conclusion, especially the learning (for future eventualities) and John's statement about "potential" that Rodney didn't "entirely" understand.

Because, yeah. Brain as big as a planet. I'll come to him.
God, what a faith ...

Great story. Thank you.
SaJi
2008-04-29 . chapter 3
"You saw potential in those books. I see it someplace else."

*points* My heart did a little flutter right there. That has got to be one of the sweetest things anyone could say to Rodney and of course he didn't get it. =3
sablecain
2008-04-28 . chapter 3
"you saw potential in those books. I see it someplace else."

I LOVE THIS. You found a lovely way to emphasize just how far Sheppard will go to save his friends, family, team. Lovely. Your descriptions are terrific and I adore how you write John and Rodney! Yay!
Cutiepie2191
2008-04-27 . chapter 3
Great story! Keep up the good work:)
zookitty
2008-04-25 . chapter 3
Rodney just doesn't learn does he? -laughs- Beautiful story. John is so wonderful! The future of atlantis didn't matter quite as much without Rodney in it -grins- Great job! Excellent writting too
-Zooky
lauren hedghog
2008-04-25 . chapter 3
A wonderful story :-)
WritingtheWrong
2008-04-24 . chapter 3
I've been a fan since your M7 days. I'm sure glad you found Rodney.

Another brilliant story. Lovely interaction between shepard and McKay and of course, some awesome whump!

Thank you

Hopefully next story coming in a couple of days?!? :) lol
angw
2008-04-24 . chapter 3
I like Sheppard's reasoning - “You saw potential in those books. I see it someplace else.” Very nice sentiment :)
Return to Top