awe...this is so great!

Awesome as always! Thank you

This was so sweet! Wonderful story.

That was beautiful. And the whole last scene definitely has me in tears. I have to go find a tissue.

Out of the mouths of babes...

I loved this line - great tension breaker mid story: “Talk to Katie,” Caleb said. “She’ll explain everything.”

Made me laugh out loud even while worrying. Actually just made me laugh again right now, even as the tear drop drip off my nose. I need to go find something less... beautiful... before curling into sleep!

I really enjoyed this piece! It was great to see Caleb, Dean and Sammy all protecting each other and their mothers' memories. Excellent! God do I wish I had a Caleb Reaves for myself!

A great ending to an even better story! I loved it!! So sad yet so freakin hilarious!! Sam's smiting line is one for the books. Where do you come up with these? Awesome!

I am so loving this story!! I'm glad that you wrote it in Caleb's POV. I LOVE Caleb. The Betty Crocker line was classic. Awesome!! Great cliffhanger ending. Thankfully I have been lax in my reading and there's a 2nd chapter now for me to read. Yeah!Awesome Fic!Kudos!

I love your Mother Day's fics! They are always so cute! I'm not aware if you've seen the season finale yet but I'm guessing you have. Is it too much to ask for a little fic with Caleb finding out Dean's gone hell-hole? Speaking of Caleb, "where was he" when the finale went down? I'd love to see some post-No Rest For the Wicked fics.

I love your writing, your creation of the Brotherhood is genius! And also amazed at how you worked in the alternate stories around the series. I'd love to know what inspired you.

Absolutely loved this story, I'm really looking forward to reading what you write next for the boys.

oh, i loved the story! thanks

sweet

This was really really cute. Loved it!

I love love love the preseries Brotherhoods! The Mothers Day ones are particularly special. Mama Winchester deserves more stories where she is remembered! Thank you!

Hey Rid - I had a thought earlier and I just had to mention it since this story kind of touches on it. In your fabulous AU - we know that Dean and Caleb have 2 major phobias. For Dean it's bears and heights, for Caleb it's water and hospitals. But with Sam all we know is clowns. So I'm thinking your Sammy has to have another fear that he was teased about - I'm just wondering what it is and if we can see it come up in a story sometime soon? Just had to ask...

Isn't Jim just the greatest. I loved the way he dealt with everybody, although Dean's defensive anger is just so heartbreaking! Hehe, I'm glad Caleb stood up for this buddies, although they were all very lucky that Jim was there to smooth things over.

Those weechesters just break my heart, and yet make me smile so much! And I love it that is usually Caleb that has to deal with the awkwardness that is mothers day each time. Does John orchestrate being away over that date, or what!