Very unique story you have started here. I can't wait to read more!

Holy crap! I don't even know what to say. That was nothing short of absolutely freakin' amazing! Your descriptions of Hell made me feel like I was literally there, and the total reinvisioning of the plotline of the original canon was absolutely brilliant and fit in with the original flawlessly. Bravo on an amazing story! I will certainly be reading more of your work in the future :)

WOW. Stunned. Had me going the whole time. I really liked this one too.

That's a really disturbing story... Loved it, of course!

Gah. This is horrible. In a wonderful kind of way. Wow.

Very wicked.

buh... buh... I thought for SURE it was Dean down there, then you revealed it was Sam and I think my brain died for the second time in a week! It can't handle much more of this! lol. Very interesting idea!

Oh...

*Shivers*

Oh the implications of this!

*Gasps for air*

Beautiful... Thank you.

*hugs*

Very interesting theory. It's really kind of left me reeling from the thought of it. wow. Sam's really in Hell and this one we've been watching for a year is only a puppet.

Amazing stuff and well done. Your descriptions of Hell were impressive.

whoa, that was nothing like i expected!
great fic :)

Am the devil on your shoulder darlin', :insert manical laughter: I love this. You know I do, and am glad you kept in the gutpunch! Makes it that much more deliciously evil.

Whoa, wow, whoa...! Assumptions will just bite you in the **, and I must say you gave nothing away in the beginning. When he could feel the door open, and he longed for the surface...The picture you painted of his hell, and just the atmosphere I felt from your word painting was just awesome. I'd really like to see the souls righted and the fallout that causes. Great story, thanks for sharing!

Powerful stuff, here! Dark and twisted but very much in keeping with the show. Though you were making such a point of not mentioning names in the first part that I had pretty much figured it had to be Sam and not Dean in that pit long before your revelation... ^^ Still, the story was really well written and I truly enjoyed it! It generates so many interesting questions and possible plot lines for a fourth season that it would make for an excellent season finale...

all I can say is...WOW!

Wow. Please, please, please at least write one more chapter for this! Who or what is in Sam's body, and why wouldn't Ruby have noticed before? As always, both very disturbing and very good.