 Sarai 2008-12-22 . chapter 1Oh LOL, I thought it would be Jadis. |
 ForceStar 2008-11-17 . chapter 1I was skimming and happened to come across this story. So right, for any number of fandoms, and SO DARN FUNNY!
Death to Sues! |
 Rosa Cotton 2008-09-16 . chapter 1HAHA! That was brilliant! Gary Stu/Mary Sue finding their way into the story, that's worse than the hag and werewolf!
These were my favorite parts:
“You believe in us, don't you Caspian dear? You know we're right... how can you deny your true love?”
Oh, just wonderful.
In that instant Peter recognized the threat. With a whispered, “Dear Aslan, not again,” he burst through the door, a livid Edmund and rather confused but still ready to fight Trumpkin not far behind.
Edmund was standing over the crumpled form of the girl, holding a rather thick book in his hands. Peter's opponent lost all interest in the duel, shouting out a prolonged, dramatic cry of “NO!” which was soon lost as Peter bashed him on the head with his shield. Edmund quickly made his way over and smacked the stunned man with the book as well.
Edmund only grinned. “Literary criticism. Sues can't stand it.”
Peter chuckled. “Ingenious.”
LOL. Great job done! God bless. |
 Starsy Skye 2008-09-13 . chapter 1*crackles up* Oh my platypus!! *crackles some more*
Oy goodness! "Ingenious" is definitely the word. :P I loved this,
"Edmund was standing over the crumpled form of the girl, holding a rather thick book in his hands. Apparently he'd just conked her on the head with it.
...
'What is that book anyway, Ed?'
Edmund only grinned. 'Literary criticism. Sues can't stand it.'"
And this,
"Peter sighed, walking over and putting a reassuring and sympathetic hand on the prince's shoulder. 'Comes with the job. Sorry, mate... you're stuck with the swarms of Sues until the next adventure.'”
Love it!! Great job. *huge grin*
Cozy slippers,
Starsy Skye |
 King Caspian the Seafarer 2008-09-11 . chapter 1;) As Peter said, "Ingenious".
That was HILARIOUS! Down with the Sues (and Stus)! Funny how Ed hit her over the head with 'Literary criticism'. I'll have to try using that...lol
Poor Caspian indeed. Great job! I was laughing hysterically by the end.
Lion be with you,
KC |
 Bat'Arieh 2008-08-31 . chapter 1Ha! Serves them right! Very well done, Petra. The descriptions, especially of the Sue & Stu, really got me. Great details! I especially liked the "piercing (but still utterly beautiful) SQUE-like shriek tearing the air." Certainly fun to read. Thanks for sharing! |
 Lekta 2008-06-21 . chapter 1That was great! Oh, the poor boys, always being stalked by Mary Sues and some Gary Stu's.
Good job. More Sue bashing! |
 ilysia 2008-06-20 . chapter 1This is brilliant. 'Literary criticism. Sues can't stand it." Much the best. Though, I have seen an awful lot of Sue-bashing going on recently. Still, great fun.
-ilysia |
 Skinny Little Nobody 2008-06-15 . chapter 1This is so funny! |
 The Grey Phantom 2008-06-11 . chapter 1That was absolutely wonderful! I think I needed to read a good sue-bonker fic! The idea was ingenious! |
 purple kimono 2008-06-05 . chapter 1Hahaha! That's so clever! Sharp and witty just like Edmund... :D After seeing all those junk about OC's and Suspians that aren't supposed to exist, this is really refreshing. I love Mary Sue bashings! They make fanfiction so much funnier.
I absolutely agree with everyone who is laughing at bashings that this is like a jewel in the middle of all that dirt. Fantastic piece of work you got here! I also love this:
"What is that book anyway, Ed?"
“Literary criticism. Sues can't stand it.”
Ingenious.”
Awesome! |
 lurkisblurkis 2008-05-31 . chapter 1I suppose we could have gotten to see a bit more of exactly why Peter and the rest feared the Sue and Stu, but other than that slight detail this is a classically well-executed parody-fic. And by "classic" I don't mean unoriginal or anything, I mean it is in line with the noble tradition and gives honor to the worthy name of Parody. A lot of fics that try to be in this same vein don't really accomplish it. So, bravo!
lurkisblurkis |
 Stripysockz 2008-05-31 . chapter 1Haha, that made me laugh so hard my mum actually asked me what was so funny! I love Mary-Sue bashing fics, and this was a pretty good one, keep up the good work! |
 BabyBeaver 2008-05-29 . chapter 1It took me a minute to realize who was there, but that was great. I love it. Mary Sues and Gary Stus are annoying (how on Earth did they get their names, anyway?), so this was enjoyable.
Keep it up! =D |
 Andi Horton 2008-05-29 . chapter 1Well, if anything could stand a good bonk on the head it has to be a Mary Sue. You've picked a worthy target at any rate!
Personally I think I will be sleeping with a book or two of literary criticism by my bed from now on, in addition to all of the original Chronicles . . . it feels safer, somehow, knowing I've got something of real substance to throw. Loved this! You wrote with a light and even hand so it isn't at all clunky, the way some parodies can turn out. Just what I needed right now, and such good fun :) |